CrazeD wrote:
JoshP wrote:
I haz it, i posted a screen in another windows 7 thread somewhere in tech
xfire me for torrent links
btw, it's an excellent OS so far. A few compatibility issues with sound, and it not detecting my wireless properly, but they are minor niggles- far better than the beta of vista when it came out.
Oh, and to all you vista-touting guys, windows 7 beta is more stable for me (no bsod's yet), and more compatible, than vista with SP1. So either my hardware hates vista but loves windows 7 and xp, or vista sucks...
Spoiler (highlight to read):
/flamebait
I'd say it's your hardware.
99% of the time, BSOD = hardware.
I haven't gotten a BSOD on XP in a very long time. I don't think I've ever had one in Vista. Vista seems more stable to me than XP. For example, sometimes a program will freeze and cause explorer to lag or become unresponsive on XP, but when the same thing happens in Vista, explorer is still completely fine and I'm able to end task said program.
Vista does not have instability issues.
Well, for me, Vista BSOD'd extremely regularly. In excess of once a day, and I didn't ever play games on my Vista install, so the hardware wasn't under much stress when it BSOD'd.
XP on the other hand, BSOD's pretty rarely, once a month at most, if i get it more than that, I reinstall Windows, which has fixed it every time I did that.
Windows 7 appears to be much more stable than Vista - on a clean install of Vista, stuff still lagged, hung, froze, etc and the processes needed killing. However on Windows 7, I haven't had a BSOD or anything freeze yet (admittedly I have only used it for ~ 10 hours, however those 10 hours have been nigh on perfect).
Also on Vista, I had strange driver issues with my graphics where I had a sort of flicker effect on my monitor, like, horizontal white lines about 2 inches long appearing in random places across the screen, about 1 every second or so, which was pretty strange and rather irritating.
With Windows 7 (bear in mind this is the same hardware I have used for all 3 o/s's), it automatically detected my monitor when installing, and set it to the correct resolution (
) and the flicker effect is also absent.
Freezing programs - in XP, i just swat them with a good old taskkill /im <process,.exe> /f /t , which works a treat. In Vista, I found that a freezing program usually ended up with a restart - which also took longer in Vista than XP.
Based on the above, beta testing Windows 7 tells me that it's an awsm o/s that needs a few compatibility tweaks, but will be epic when it's RTM.
XP has been a great o/s for me for the past 3 years, and i've had very few problems with it.
On the other hand, each time I try Vista, I get plagued with compatibility issues, driver issues, strange monitor flicker, and general instablity.
Windows 7, for me, has fixed all the problems with Vista - and is, basically, what I wish Vista was
tl;dr win7 > xp > vista
Edit: longpost is long
Also - my opinions on XP, Vista, and Windows 7 are solely based on my experiences with them, because, well, that's what matters to me
Last edited by JoshP (2008-12-31 11:16:12)