science question

2009-02-04 12:27:53

#1

Mitch: 16 more years; +877|6964|South Florida

If ice expands when frozen, such as leaving an unopened can in the cold, it breaks through the can cause it has no space.

What happens, if you fill a very strong steel container to the very fullest point, weld it air tight shut, and put it in a freezer.

The water would be forced to change to ice, but it would have to expand, but it cant because you have a 5 inch thick steel cube containing it.

What would then happen?

thanks

15 more years! 15 more years!

2009-02-04 12:30:21

#2

Sydney: 2λчиэλ; +783|7282|Reykjavík, Iceland.

Black hole.

2009-02-04 12:31:35

#3

CanadianLoser: Meow :3 :3; +1,148|6946

it wouldn't expand.

2009-02-04 12:32:15

#4

wensleydale8: Member; +81|7208|LEEDS!!!!!, Yorkshire

wouldnt it become a supercooled but thats given your cooling it to below -42 degrees C

Otherwise it will just break the steel regardless.

Last edited by wensleydale8 (2009-02-04 12:34:53)

Dear God please let my karma one day reach 100, whether it be tomorrow or 1000 years in the future i want it to happen.

2009-02-04 12:32:27

#5

Brasso: member; +1,549|7069

my guess is that it would break the steel. there's also a possibility that it would just stay in its original state, water, although i think that's unlikely.

"people in ny have a general idea of how to drive. one of the pedals goes forward the other one prevents you from dying"

2009-02-04 12:35:19

#6

Parker: isteal; +1,452|6833|The Gem Saloon

well, steel contracts when it is cold, so there would be two forces working against one another.

my guess would be that the weakest weld would break, and the water/ice would find its space that way.

2009-02-04 12:37:59

#7

blah: macaroni with cheeseeee; +111|6186|Croatia

I think nothing

2009-02-04 12:38:06

#8

Mitch: 16 more years; +877|6964|South Florida

OP here, i found this.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index … 404AA0Ux9O

What is the definitive answer given? I'm reading through it but so many different people say different things. What would you say?

I think the best answer there is that it just wouldnt freeze

Restating my question: An incredibly strong container cooling water to the lowest possible temp

15 more years! 15 more years!

2009-02-04 12:38:15

#9

notorious: Nay vee, bay bee.; +1,396|7186|The United Center

It would either remain water or it would break through the steel.

2009-02-04 12:38:32

#10

notorious: Nay vee, bay bee.; +1,396|7186|The United Center

Also, submit it to mythbusters.

2009-02-04 12:40:37

#11

Brasso: member; +1,549|7069

ThomasMorgan wrote:
It would either remain water or it would break through the steel.

i win

ThomasMorgan wrote:
Also, submit it to mythbusters.

mod double post

"people in ny have a general idea of how to drive. one of the pedals goes forward the other one prevents you from dying"

2009-02-04 12:46:38

#12

NooBesT: Pizzahitler; +873|6908

Pressure inside would rise thus lowering the melting point thus it would stay as water.

Or the steel could break and then the water would freeze.

Last edited by NooBesT (2009-02-04 12:48:29)

2009-02-04 12:55:52

#13

kylef: Gone; +1,352|6932|N. Ireland

Was going to say what Noobest said - pressurization extreme (no pun).

2009-02-04 12:56:09

#14

Finray: Hup! Dos, Tres, Cuatro; +2,629|6227|Catherine Black

Mitch wrote:
OP here

We know.

I'm pretty sure if it was under enough pressure it wouldn't freeze. It's like water at the bottom of the ocean, under immense pressure, and well below freezing, but the water on top of it prevents it from freezing.

2009-02-04 13:37:57

#15

FatherTed: xD; +3,936|6939|so randum

I don't think the container you describe would be adequate to stop the expansion.

Like parker says, the container will contract too, creating small fractures in the material (known in geog as the freeze-thaw process). Pretty sure it would give

Small hourglass island
Always raining and foggy
Use an umbrella

2009-02-04 13:45:27

#16

menzo: ̏̏̏̏̏̏̏̏&#; +616|6885|Amsterdam‫

if there is no way of it to expand, it wont freeze it is called super cooled water.
it happens in the arctic, if there is a small crack in the ice, the water will burst in and a big lump will fall off

https://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee37/menzo2003/fredbf2.png

2009-02-04 13:55:02

#17

Aries_37: arrivederci frog; +368|7014|London

the water gets cold

2009-02-04 13:55:45

#18

Scorpion0x17: can detect anyone's visible post count...; +691|7205|Cambridge (UK)

menzo2003 wrote:
if there is no way for it to expand, it wont freeze it is called super cooled water.

2009-02-04 15:14:39

#19

Ryan: Member; +1,230|7282|Alberta, Canada

End of the world.

2009-02-04 15:17:50

#20

Flaming_Maniac: prince of insufficient light; +2,490|7146|67.222.138.85

Water expands because small gaps are formed between the hydrogen bonds that hold the water molecules together when it's frozen. No space for the bonds to form, no frozen water.

2009-02-04 15:23:44

#21

Finray: Hup! Dos, Tres, Cuatro; +2,629|6227|Catherine Black

/0?

https://farm2.static.flickr.com/1213/1466167400_b57d0aa731_o.jpg

https://halshop.files.wordpress.com/2007/03/phpw9jvl0pm.jpg

https://images.encyclopediadramatica.com/images/6/69/Divide_by_zer0.jpg

2009-02-04 15:52:21

#22

mkxiii: online bf2s mek evasion; +509|6675|Uk

it will stay as water

2009-02-04 16:03:16

#23

rdx-fx: ...; +955|7030

It will stay as water.

No room to expand into a crystalline structure (i.e. ice) = no ice.

But you're going to need a tough container to do that. steel expands elastically under pressure, even if only a microscopic amount. A non-elastic like diamond or ceramic would just shatter at a critical pressure.

Another way to think about it; The pressurized water in your car's radiator. Plenty of heat in it to turn into steam, but as long as it's contained and below a critical pressure/temperature, it won't turn to steam.. until some dumbass opens the cap.

Last analogy: shake up a soda bottle. pressure builds, but nothing dramatic happens until you open the cap.

2009-02-04 16:35:13

#24

CrazeD: Member; +368|7112|Maine

You can't compress water. If it became ice, it would either bend/break the steel, or stay water.

2009-02-04 21:39:09

#25

Beduin: Compensation of Reactive Power in the grid; +510|6189|شمال

Finray wrote:
/0?

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1213/146 … a731_o.jpg
http://halshop.files.wordpress.com/2007 … jvl0pm.jpg
http://images.encyclopediadramatica.com … y_zer0.jpg

Sneaky bastard...0 you say??

الشعب يريد اسقاط النظام
...show me the schematic

BF2S Forums science question

ThomasMorgan wrote:

ThomasMorgan wrote:

Mitch wrote:

menzo2003 wrote:

Finray wrote:

Board footer