Shocking wrote:
lowing wrote:
Well as I have maintained throughout my time on this forum, I believe in helping those that help themselves, an earthquake, a flood, a house fire are unarguably situations that are well beyond their control. Why wouldn't I help my neighbors? They are hard working, have kids etc...
No it is not a consequence of a free society emulating personal responsibility and individualism. It is criminal behavior, nothing more than taking advantage of those you can exploit. No need to read into that.
Well, you're really just wrong about that assessment, there's not much more I can add to the argument I made. It's really not as simple as "the japanese have honor" or something like that, a country's government as a whole usually reflects the social values people hold. And
especially when something like a natural disaster hits, you're going to fall back on the way of life that you have been carrying around for as long as you lived.
We're talking about a situation in which not only your neighbour's house burns down, but yours as well, and every other house in the street for that matter. You expect Americans to suddenly turn from the individualism that has been at the core of your society for centuries, to supporting everyone around them? Not a chance.
Ummmm 'the way of life I have been carrying around for as long as I lived" is not one of rapping or murdering my neighbors and shooting people trying to help me. Remember, we are not talking about 3 weeks later or something, when people get desperate, and start to fight for survival, we are talking about the VERY NEXT DAY!
As an example, the US and the American generosity is now, and usually is, first on the scene with aid. THat fact alone does not support your opinion.
It is not my gut instinct to turn to killing looting or raping my community as a result of being responsible and free. sorry.
As I said, I don't recall hearing stories of rape murder looting and shooting emergency workers coming out of any other city or town hit by Katrina, and we all are under the same govt.
What about the communities that get hit with tornadoes, there are no reports of rape and murder and shooting aid workers in any of those examples either. It is your assessment that might be wrong.
Last edited by lowing (2011-03-18 15:51:25)