Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|6957|Long Island, New York
Figured I'd get more mature answers in this forum.

So, they had this thing called the "Career Awareness Day" at my school. People from stores, radio stations, the military, etc came to what looked like an Expo in our gym. I went to the Air Force station and told them (recruiters) I was already planning on joining, but I asked what was the chance I'd actually be able to fly. He said if you have your bachelor's degree in Professional Aviation, you're more than likely going to get a chance to fly. I told him I was planning on joining the AF for a long time, but wasn't sure whether I should go to college (Embry-Riddle is where I'm aiming for) first and then become an officer, or just enlist right out of college. He told me that enlisting right after college will not only pay for itself, but teach me everything that Embry-Riddle would, but for free. He asked if I wanted to put my parents in debt. :S

I just responded with "...is that a trick question?"

So, my question here is: Should I join the Air Force after high school and get my education at the Community College of the Air Force (CCAF), or should I go through 4 years of real college, get my Bachelor's in Professional Aviation, and then graduate and become an Officer where I'll be able to fly a lot sooner?
Major.League.Infidel
Make Love and War
+303|6897|Communist Republic of CA, USA
College first.
lowing
Banned
+1,662|7070|USA
College first. I promise.
FatherTed
xD
+3,936|6919|so randum

lowing wrote:

College first. I promise.
Because then if you decide you don't like the military life, you can always do well as a civie?

I'm going uni before i think about the RAF, just so i'm not tying myself down to anything yet.
Small hourglass island
Always raining and foggy
Use an umbrella
lowing
Banned
+1,662|7070|USA

FatherTed wrote:

lowing wrote:

College first. I promise.
Because then if you decide you don't like the military life, you can always do well as a civie?

I'm going uni before i think about the RAF, just so i'm not tying myself down to anything yet.
Nope, as an officer, all avenues are open to you. You will not be restricted by "officer only" career fields, such as pilot. Just one advantage. Better housing, better pay etc.....
imortal
Member
+240|7084|Austin, TX
I would say the military first.  Do not forget about other benifits from military service, such as the GI Bill.  That gives you a lot of money to help you through college.  Second, being a little older going through college helps.  You are just going to have to trust me on this; students who start college later do much better in school.  Also, having more 'experience' under your belt when you get to college will make you much more popular there.
SenorToenails
Veritas et Scientia
+444|6549|North Tonawanda, NY
College first.  It seems like a no brainer.
HurricaИe
Banned
+877|6380|Washington DC

imortal wrote:

I would say the military first.  Do not forget about other benifits from military service, such as the GI Bill.  That gives you a lot of money to help you through college.  Second, being a little older going through college helps.  You are just going to have to trust me on this; students who start college later do much better in school.  Also, having more 'experience' under your belt when you get to college will make you much more popular there.
a challenger appears!
imortal
Member
+240|7084|Austin, TX

HurricaИe wrote:

imortal wrote:

I would say the military first.  Do not forget about other benifits from military service, such as the GI Bill.  That gives you a lot of money to help you through college.  Second, being a little older going through college helps.  You are just going to have to trust me on this; students who start college later do much better in school.  Also, having more 'experience' under your belt when you get to college will make you much more popular there.
a challenger appears!
Well, I have been to college, and I have been in the military.  My college experience comes from before AND from after my army experience.  I sure know how I feel about it, and how my experiences were.
HurricaИe
Banned
+877|6380|Washington DC

imortal wrote:

HurricaИe wrote:

imortal wrote:

I would say the military first.  Do not forget about other benifits from military service, such as the GI Bill.  That gives you a lot of money to help you through college.  Second, being a little older going through college helps.  You are just going to have to trust me on this; students who start college later do much better in school.  Also, having more 'experience' under your belt when you get to college will make you much more popular there.
a challenger appears!
Well, I have been to college, and I have been in the military.  My college experience comes from before AND from after my army experience.  I sure know how I feel about it, and how my experiences were.
I wasn't doubting the validity of your post... just pointing out how first some folks said college first, then you said military first... this will make for a good discussion.
Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|6957|Long Island, New York

imortal wrote:

I would say the military first.  Do not forget about other benifits from military service, such as the GI Bill.  That gives you a lot of money to help you through college.  Second, being a little older going through college helps.  You are just going to have to trust me on this; students who start college later do much better in school.  Also, having more 'experience' under your belt when you get to college will make you much more popular there.
Yeah, they were telling me about the Montgomery GI Bill and everything.

God, this is such a toss up at this point...

FatherTed wrote:

lowing wrote:

College first. I promise.
Because then if you decide you don't like the military life, you can always do well as a civie?

I'm going uni before i think about the RAF, just so i'm not tying myself down to anything yet.
Well, I'm pretty much 99.9% positive my career will involve flight. Plus, if I go into the military, spend 4-10 years there, and do my service...I'll have a better chance of being a commercial pilot afterwards like I intend to.
Nyte
Legendary BF2S Veteran
+535|7171|Toronto, ON
Military first, because once you get killed in combat then your parents don't have to pay for college.
Alpha as fuck.
R0lyP0ly
Member
+161|7073|USA
Do what i did. Get an ROTC scholarship that makes college free, you get your education, and then you join the military.

and if you really want to be a pilot, join the Navy. Seriously. Not the air force.
Poseidon
Fudgepack DeQueef
+3,253|6957|Long Island, New York

Nyte wrote:

Military first, because once you get killed in combat then your parents don't have to pay for college.
Yeah, thanks a lot. Real useful information. Dickhead.

lowing
Banned
+1,662|7070|USA

R0lyP0ly wrote:

Do what i did. Get an ROTC scholarship that makes college free, you get your education, and then you join the military.

and if you really want to be a pilot, join the Navy. Seriously. Not the air force.
Good advice here Poseidon. Only thing is, join the branch that best suits you. The who is better, Navy, or Air Force, is nothing more than a pissing contest. Not many airlines care how many carrier night traps you have, just how many flight hours you have.
imortal
Member
+240|7084|Austin, TX

lowing wrote:

R0lyP0ly wrote:

Do what i did. Get an ROTC scholarship that makes college free, you get your education, and then you join the military.

and if you really want to be a pilot, join the Navy. Seriously. Not the air force.
Good advice here Poseidon. Only thing is, join the branch that best suits you. The who is better, Navy, or Air Force, is nothing more than a pissing contest. Not many airlines care how many carrier night traps you have, just how many flight hours you have.
Also, if your goal is to become an airline pilot, concentrate on the larger, less sexy aircraft.  Try to fly the tankers, AWACS, transports.  It is not as sexy as a fighter pilot, but it is still flying, and it is a great experience.

Another reason to think of the military first is time.  If you are stationed stateside, you have free time.  You can go to a community college, you can get your civilian pilot's license and work on your ratings.  Then, once you get out of the military, you already have college credits, and will not spend as much time in school, or you can take fewer classes and either work or enjoy the spare time.

Look at it this way:  Spend 4 years in the Air Force (for example).  While in the airforce, you go to community college, get your common cprerequisite classes out of the way (for considerably less money, I might add).  Then, when you get out of the Air Force, you get your college done in not 4, but in 2 to 3 years.

Why do I say for 4 years?  There is one more benifit I did not mention.  If you become an officer after being enlisted for 4 years, you get a considerable pay increase.  From the 2008 pay scale, an O1 (2nd Leutinant or an Ensign) fresh from college makes $2543.40 a month.  If you have 4 years of enlisted experience under your belt before becoming an officer, an O1 makes $3199.80.

The path I am suggesting takes the long way around, yes.  But you seem to be taking the long view anyway; it helps to have options to look at.  One last thing.  If you DO decide to go into the Air Force before college, or another military branch, there is the question of what you should do.  Again, there are two paths to take.  Either you specialize in a skill that will make you better at your eventual career (A&P mechanic or meterology) or you decide to do something fun and completlely different, so you can have different and broader experiences.
lowing
Banned
+1,662|7070|USA

imortal wrote:

lowing wrote:

R0lyP0ly wrote:

Do what i did. Get an ROTC scholarship that makes college free, you get your education, and then you join the military.

and if you really want to be a pilot, join the Navy. Seriously. Not the air force.
Good advice here Poseidon. Only thing is, join the branch that best suits you. The who is better, Navy, or Air Force, is nothing more than a pissing contest. Not many airlines care how many carrier night traps you have, just how many flight hours you have.
Also, if your goal is to become an airline pilot, concentrate on the larger, less sexy aircraft.  Try to fly the tankers, AWACS, transports.  It is not as sexy as a fighter pilot, but it is still flying, and it is a great experience.

Another reason to think of the military first is time.  If you are stationed stateside, you have free time.  You can go to a community college, you can get your civilian pilot's license and work on your ratings.  Then, once you get out of the military, you already have college credits, and will not spend as much time in school, or you can take fewer classes and either work or enjoy the spare time.

Look at it this way:  Spend 4 years in the Air Force (for example).  While in the airforce, you go to community college, get your common cprerequisite classes out of the way (for considerably less money, I might add).  Then, when you get out of the Air Force, you get your college done in not 4, but in 2 to 3 years.

Why do I say for 4 years?  There is one more benifit I did not mention.  If you become an officer after being enlisted for 4 years, you get a considerable pay increase.  From the 2008 pay scale, an O1 (2nd Leutinant or an Ensign) fresh from college makes $2543.40 a month.  If you have 4 years of enlisted experience under your belt before becoming an officer, an O1 makes $3199.80.

The path I am suggesting takes the long way around, yes.  But you seem to be taking the long view anyway; it helps to have options to look at.  One last thing.  If you DO decide to go into the Air Force before college, or another military branch, there is the question of what you should do.  Again, there are two paths to take.  Either you specialize in a skill that will make you better at your eventual career (A&P mechanic or meterology) or you decide to do something fun and completlely different, so you can have different and broader experiences.
HOWEVER!!, In the real world, working all day, exercises, deployments, weekend duty, etc......leaves little time for classes, even if you were awake enough to take them.

Why spend money on a pilots license when you can get all of your ratings for free while you fly in the military? Concentrate on one thing first 100%. Then move on to the next and concentrate on it 100%. 4 years of college and 6 years in the military afterwards to build your flying resume.
Masques
Black Panzer Party
+184|7141|Eastern PA
Why not AFROTC?

You can earn college credit for a large percentage of your military courses. Additionally you can get credit for some activities outside of college depending on your academic program. For example, a friend of mine majored in aerospace engineering and was able to get 12 credits (equal to a semester as a full time student) by taking flying lessons.
imortal
Member
+240|7084|Austin, TX

lowing wrote:

imortal wrote:

lowing wrote:

Good advice here Poseidon. Only thing is, join the branch that best suits you. The who is better, Navy, or Air Force, is nothing more than a pissing contest. Not many airlines care how many carrier night traps you have, just how many flight hours you have.
Also, if your goal is to become an airline pilot, concentrate on the larger, less sexy aircraft.  Try to fly the tankers, AWACS, transports.  It is not as sexy as a fighter pilot, but it is still flying, and it is a great experience.

Another reason to think of the military first is time.  If you are stationed stateside, you have free time.  You can go to a community college, you can get your civilian pilot's license and work on your ratings.  Then, once you get out of the military, you already have college credits, and will not spend as much time in school, or you can take fewer classes and either work or enjoy the spare time.

Look at it this way:  Spend 4 years in the Air Force (for example).  While in the airforce, you go to community college, get your common cprerequisite classes out of the way (for considerably less money, I might add).  Then, when you get out of the Air Force, you get your college done in not 4, but in 2 to 3 years.

Why do I say for 4 years?  There is one more benifit I did not mention.  If you become an officer after being enlisted for 4 years, you get a considerable pay increase.  From the 2008 pay scale, an O1 (2nd Leutinant or an Ensign) fresh from college makes $2543.40 a month.  If you have 4 years of enlisted experience under your belt before becoming an officer, an O1 makes $3199.80.

The path I am suggesting takes the long way around, yes.  But you seem to be taking the long view anyway; it helps to have options to look at.  One last thing.  If you DO decide to go into the Air Force before college, or another military branch, there is the question of what you should do.  Again, there are two paths to take.  Either you specialize in a skill that will make you better at your eventual career (A&P mechanic or meterology) or you decide to do something fun and completlely different, so you can have different and broader experiences.
HOWEVER!!, In the real world, working all day, exercises, deployments, weekend duty, etc......leaves little time for classes, even if you were awake enough to take them.

Why spend money on a pilots license when you can get all of your ratings for free while you fly in the military? Concentrate on one thing first 100%. Then move on to the next and concentrate on it 100%. 4 years of college and 6 years in the military afterwards to build your flying resume.
Granted, if you become a pilot, the Air Force will teach you to fly.  But there is nothing preventing you from learning earlier and flying for fun instead of for pay.  And while there is late evening and weekend duties that will take some of your time, the Air Force will keep you around the base, unlike the Army and Marines, which needs to take you into the field for realistic training.  If you live on base, you can still make it to your own bed each night.

I KNOW you can get classes in while in the military.  I have seen people do it.  I did not, mainly because I was not that far-sighted at the time.  IF I could do it again, you better believe I would.  I was in the army 8 years.  In that time, I had 1 tour in Iraq, 2 tours in Bosnia, 1 month fighting forest fires, and got slogged out into the mud and the woods for 2 to 4 months so many times I lost count.  And yet, I STILL could have easily have taken classes.  At most military bases, there are community colleges that have many, many military students.  They are used to the... unusual schedules military service creates.

EDIT:  Also, fresh out of high school and in the military, you have a unique situation, money-wise.  The military pays for your food, pays for your housing.  And they pay you.  The question becomes what you use your money for.  A lot of young servicemembers party, using their money on partying, flashy cars, electronics.  When your entire paycheck is basically disposable income, you tend to dispose of your income.  If you can resist that impulse, and set some money aside for saving and education, you will be better set up for life.  And using your money for productive goals means less money to get yourself in trouble with.

Last edited by imortal (2008-04-12 18:26:32)

acEofspadEs6313
Shiny! Let's be bad guys.
+102|7112|NAS Jacksonville, Florida
Here's my input on it.

I just turned 19 in February, and I've been in the Navy for almost nine months now. I didn't really think about the whole college agenda when I joined, since I joined to primarily try for the SEALs. (Which has now changed to USMC Force Reconnaissance, due to being a Corpsman!) It is possible to do courses while in the military. Right now, I work at the hospital at NAS Jacksonville. My work rotation is 5 days a week one week, then 2 days the next week, repeated, for 12 hours a day. If I wanted to, I could go do some courses, but the position I'm in I can't since I'm working the day shift and focusing on refining my skills as a Corpsman, instead of working nights and going to courses during the day.

It all depends on what your specialty is in whatever branch you're in. The life of a Corpsman in a hospital is much different from that of an Aviation Boatswain's Mate, or of a Yeoman.



Ok, as for joining before or after college, I personally would say join before. There are loads of benefits you can get from it. For example, in the Navy, there's the STA-21 program which allows enlisted sailors who still have time on their contract go to college while getting paid for three years to get a Bachelors Degree, and then give time back to the Navy as an officer.
lowing
Banned
+1,662|7070|USA

imortal wrote:

lowing wrote:

imortal wrote:


Also, if your goal is to become an airline pilot, concentrate on the larger, less sexy aircraft.  Try to fly the tankers, AWACS, transports.  It is not as sexy as a fighter pilot, but it is still flying, and it is a great experience.

Another reason to think of the military first is time.  If you are stationed stateside, you have free time.  You can go to a community college, you can get your civilian pilot's license and work on your ratings.  Then, once you get out of the military, you already have college credits, and will not spend as much time in school, or you can take fewer classes and either work or enjoy the spare time.

Look at it this way:  Spend 4 years in the Air Force (for example).  While in the airforce, you go to community college, get your common cprerequisite classes out of the way (for considerably less money, I might add).  Then, when you get out of the Air Force, you get your college done in not 4, but in 2 to 3 years.

Why do I say for 4 years?  There is one more benifit I did not mention.  If you become an officer after being enlisted for 4 years, you get a considerable pay increase.  From the 2008 pay scale, an O1 (2nd Leutinant or an Ensign) fresh from college makes $2543.40 a month.  If you have 4 years of enlisted experience under your belt before becoming an officer, an O1 makes $3199.80.

The path I am suggesting takes the long way around, yes.  But you seem to be taking the long view anyway; it helps to have options to look at.  One last thing.  If you DO decide to go into the Air Force before college, or another military branch, there is the question of what you should do.  Again, there are two paths to take.  Either you specialize in a skill that will make you better at your eventual career (A&P mechanic or meterology) or you decide to do something fun and completlely different, so you can have different and broader experiences.
HOWEVER!!, In the real world, working all day, exercises, deployments, weekend duty, etc......leaves little time for classes, even if you were awake enough to take them.

Why spend money on a pilots license when you can get all of your ratings for free while you fly in the military? Concentrate on one thing first 100%. Then move on to the next and concentrate on it 100%. 4 years of college and 6 years in the military afterwards to build your flying resume.
Granted, if you become a pilot, the Air Force will teach you to fly.  But there is nothing preventing you from learning earlier and flying for fun instead of for pay.  And while there is late evening and weekend duties that will take some of your time, the Air Force will keep you around the base, unlike the Army and Marines, which needs to take you into the field for realistic training.  If you live on base, you can still make it to your own bed each night.

I KNOW you can get classes in while in the military.  I have seen people do it.  I did not, mainly because I was not that far-sighted at the time.  IF I could do it again, you better believe I would.  I was in the army 8 years.  In that time, I had 1 tour in Iraq, 2 tours in Bosnia, 1 month fighting forest fires, and got slogged out into the mud and the woods for 2 to 4 months so many times I lost count.  And yet, I STILL could have easily have taken classes.  At most military bases, there are community colleges that have many, many military students.  They are used to the... unusual schedules military service creates.

EDIT:  Also, fresh out of high school and in the military, you have a unique situation, money-wise.  The military pays for your food, pays for your housing.  And they pay you.  The question becomes what you use your money for.  A lot of young servicemembers party, using their money on partying, flashy cars, electronics.  When your entire paycheck is basically disposable income, you tend to dispose of your income.  If you can resist that impulse, and set some money aside for saving and education, you will be better set up for life.  And using your money for productive goals means less money to get yourself in trouble with.
Well, what you suggest can be done, and has been, but c'mon really, why put all of that on a person that actually has a choice between college BEFORE military and college DURING military? Why subject yourself to all of the enlisted bullshit when they do not really need to put up with it?

I was enlisted in the Air Force, I got my A&P while I was in, and went on to an airline career ( actually several) I am also a private pilot.

The thing is, what you suggest works for people that do not have many options. Poseidon apparently does.
FEOS
Bellicose Yankee Air Pirate
+1,182|6830|'Murka

Keep in mind that most military IPs prefer someone who doesn't already have a PPL. In their words, they don't have to teach the student to "unlearn" bad habits. So...an aviation-related degree doesn't buy you much WRT military flight school. So long as you score high enough on your AFOQT and BAT, you'll get selected for UPT and learn to fly on Uncle Sam's dime.

There is definitely a lot of truth to what imortal posted. If you aren't sure if you're ready for college (or don't have the money), a basic enlistment will certainly get you ready for college. Things that seemed so difficult in college are actually dead simple with some real world experience under your belt...particularly if it's in the same field. Regardless, the maturity you gain with a few years on active duty will prepare you well for college.

If you really want to fly right off the bat, I recommend applying for the AFA. If you meet physical qualifications, you're pretty much guaranteed a shot at UPT.
“Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”
― Albert Einstein

Doing the popular thing is not always right. Doing the right thing is not always popular
imortal
Member
+240|7084|Austin, TX

lowing wrote:

Well, what you suggest can be done, and has been, but c'mon really, why put all of that on a person that actually has a choice between college BEFORE military and college DURING military? Why subject yourself to all of the enlisted bullshit when they do not really need to put up with it?

I was enlisted in the Air Force, I got my A&P while I was in, and went on to an airline career ( actually several) I am also a private pilot.

The thing is, what you suggest works for people that do not have many options. Poseidon apparently does.
My first college experience was straight out of high school and was basically a waste of time, education-wise.  A few years in the military made a world of difference for me, discipline-wise, and is helping me to make my way through college much more successfully this time.

The military is not just a way out for people who have few options.  It helps create options.  Military service can also be a (metaphorical) mirror; helping you look at yourself in different enviroements and helping put to the test your dreams and goals.  Not to mention free training and pretty easy money.  Not to mention that I was army, and I do view enlisted in the Air Force as... more comfortable. 

I found it humorous that you followed a similar track I was suggesting.  There are so many people here suggesting college, then military.  It is the more traditional, I grant you.  I went to a military college first, and saw that life from the inside.  I am presenting an alternative method of getting to Poseidon's goals.  Options are rarely a bad thing.

Though I think it a bit pretentious of us discussing his future here while he sits back and observes.  Poseidon, how is your thinking going?  I hope you have time to seriously think about all of this.  It is not a descision to make lightly.  There are various ways to get to your goals.  Beware of recruiters, either college or military.  Listen to them, gather information.  Even get suggestions from us.  But make your own descision.
acEofspadEs6313
Shiny! Let's be bad guys.
+102|7112|NAS Jacksonville, Florida

imortal wrote:

The military is not just a way out for people who have few options.  It helps create options.  Military service can also be a (metaphorical) mirror; helping you look at yourself in different enviroements and helping put to the test your dreams and goals.  Not to mention free training and pretty easy money.  Not to mention that I was army, and I do view enlisted in the Air Force as... more comfortable.
Fun fact of the day...

The Air Force pay their personnel if they have to live in a Navy barracks.
CoronadoSEAL
pics or it didn't happen
+207|6937|USA
think about what you want from the next few years of your life.
if i could go back 3 years, i would have gone military first. 
i didn't look at what i wanted, and i payed for it.  i don't regret my decision, however, because it has contributed to who i am today (and i like that), but if i could go back, i would have enlisted (coming from a college junior). 

here are a few suggestions i gave hurri that you might benefit from.

tell us what you do.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard