EA should make the Knife throwable!?

2006-02-22 07:01:01

#1

Darth_Rambo: Member; +22|6968|Raleigh, NC

Yes or No? Thoughts.......

I think it would be cool to have throwable and retrievable knifes! If Rambo and Commando can
do it, then we should be able to in the game.....hehe.

I think an mod for BF Vietnam allowed this very thing.

2006-02-22 07:55:52

#2

Bernadictus: Moderator; +1,055|6998

Uhm, I believe Soldier Of Fortune had this option, and honestly; im opposed, what's next? Beating an enemy to death with a m11-87 ' duke nukem' style?

2006-02-22 08:08:08

#3

Kung Jew: That one mod; +331|7006|Houston, TX

Bernadictus wrote:
Uhm, I believe Soldier Of Fortune had this option, and honestly; im opposed, what's next? Beating an enemy to death with a m11-87 ' duke nukem' style?

"I'd buy that for a dollar!"

That or a good rifle butt to the face. Either would be a great asset.

KJ

2006-02-22 08:15:20

#4

Darth_Rambo: Member; +22|6968|Raleigh, NC

Kung Jew wrote:
Bernadictus wrote:
Uhm, I believe Soldier Of Fortune had this option, and honestly; im opposed, what's next? Beating an enemy to death with a m11-87 ' duke nukem' style?
"I'd buy that for a dollar!"

That or a good rifle butt to the face. Either would be a great asset.

KJ

Yep, a nice melee attack with your rifle would be cool too! Just adding alittle more depth to the game.

I have never played SOF, so I'm pretty sure a BF:Vietnam Mod had it in place.

2006-02-22 08:16:55

#5

madsmao: Member; +0|7054|Copenhagen, Denmark

Knife throwing, wrench whacking and hand to hand combat in general would be sweet. Perhaps it would make the game to much of an infantry game though and that already seems to be a problem the way it is now.

2006-02-22 08:18:45

#6

Scorpian65: Member; +14|6999

Bernadictus wrote:
Uhm, I believe Soldier Of Fortune had this option, and honestly; im opposed, what's next? Beating an enemy to death with a m11-87 ' duke nukem' style?

Coming from MOH-Spearhead I'd love to have the ability to bash someones skull in. When your low on ammo and have the jump on them but no time for knife the butt end of your weapon works great.

2006-02-22 08:18:51

#7

Kaosdad: Whisky Tango Foxtrot?; +201|6940|Broadlands, VA

Psssttt.... Search Keyword: "Throwable" Search result: http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=12208

2006-02-22 08:21:42

#8

Darth_Rambo: Member; +22|6968|Raleigh, NC

madsmao wrote:
Knife throwing, wrench whacking and hand to hand combat in general would be sweet. Perhaps it would make the game to much of an infantry game though and that already seems to be a problem the way it is now.

Wrench whacking would be AWESOME!!! Good one!

2006-02-22 08:23:48

#9

Darth_Rambo: Member; +22|6968|Raleigh, NC

Kaosdad008 wrote:
Psssttt.... Search Keyword: "Throwable" Search result: http://forums.bf2s.com/viewtopic.php?id=12208

Yeah, no shit! But when the 'Search' takes longer than 1 min, then forget it!

2006-02-22 08:30:09

#10

BerryBlastKoolAid: Member; +0|6936

madsmao wrote:
Knife throwing, wrench whacking and hand to hand combat in general would be sweet. Perhaps it would make the game to much of an infantry game though and that already seems to be a problem the way it is now.

I think the medic should also be able to beat someone with a medkit.

2006-03-07 03:01:59

#11

subtotal: Member; +0|6887

i think some kits should have a bayonet in place of a knife, and all weapons should have a melee attack

2006-03-07 05:17:51

#12

Arturo_Vittorino: Member; +0|6892|Colombia

agree all weapons should have an melee atk but for the knife i think that would be better if u only slash with it cuz its an real option, i mean u could trow the knife but r u sure that it would hit with the edge? so slashing is a better option for me.

Last edited by Arturo_Vittorino (2006-03-07 05:19:12)

2006-03-07 05:25:56

#13

rustynutz: I am British!; +124|6943|England and damn proud

theres a mod for bf2 with throwable knives its called mercinaries

2006-03-07 08:03:13

#14

unnamednewbie13: Moderator; +2,053|7032|PNW

The knife already kills with one shot. If you need to take someone out at any other range, equip your pistol. If given the option, I'd carry extra magazines before grabbing throwing knives.

2006-03-07 08:10:02

#15

sparklet: Banned; +34|7008|stop corecting my grammer!!!!!

or use a a ammo bag and havea pillow fight

2006-03-07 08:12:39

#16

unnamednewbie13: Moderator; +2,053|7032|PNW

sparklet wrote:
or use a a ammo bag and havea pillow fight

That would be funny if you could kill someone with thirty pounds of dropped ammo, but which would come first? The resupply point or the punish?

Last edited by unnamednewbie13 (2006-03-07 08:13:04)

2006-03-07 08:17:17

#17

Aardcore: Member; +60|6974|USA, Arizona

Oh my God! LOL What?! As soon as I read this as one of the forum posts on the BF2S main, I had to start laughing and check this out. That would be a HORRIBLE idea! But in some weird and chaotic way, hilarious as hell. Everyone would be stock Assault kits using the smoke grenades pretending their ninjas.

I know I'd do that:

*In the heat of combat, bullets and explosions, a single gas grenade is tossed out*
Aardcore: NINJA VANISH!
*Gas grenade explodes as smoke spills a small area of the battlefield and suddenly the sound of flying steel sounds as an infamous Battlefield 2 death scream sounds*
Aardcore [Knife] Unwillingopponent

2006-03-07 08:17:34

#18

Longbow: Member; +163|6907|Odessa, Ukraine

I think that throwing knifes ability must be included in SF only . In vanilla a hit with stock is needed .

2006-03-07 08:19:23

#19

Aardcore: Member; +60|6974|USA, Arizona

Darth_Rambo wrote:
madsmao wrote:
Knife throwing, wrench whacking and hand to hand combat in general would be sweet. Perhaps it would make the game to much of an infantry game though and that already seems to be a problem the way it is now.
Wrench whacking would be AWESOME!!! Good one!

Ah! LOL Half-Life action! LOL

2006-03-07 09:08:00

#20

unnamednewbie13: Moderator; +2,053|7032|PNW

Aardcore wrote:
Oh my God! LOL What?! As soon as I read this as one of the forum posts on the BF2S main, I had to start laughing and check this out. That would be a HORRIBLE idea! But in some weird and chaotic way, hilarious as hell. Everyone would be stock Assault kits using the smoke grenades pretending their ninjas.

I know I'd do that:

*In the heat of combat, bullets and explosions, a single gas grenade is tossed out*
Aardcore: NINJA VANISH!
*Gas grenade explodes as smoke spills a small area of the battlefield and suddenly the sound of flying steel sounds as an infamous Battlefield 2 death scream sounds*
Aardcore [Knife] Unwillingopponent

It's still possible. Grab the assault kit, pop a smoke on some infantry taking a flag, and run in with your knife blazing.

2006-03-08 18:08:08

#21

EvilJebus: Member; +11|6885

NO! This isn't Ninja Gaiden, no GI is going to throw his knife at some guy. First of all it probably wont kill the guy, just piss him off, it might not even make it past the body armor if he's wearing any. Throwing Knife = Useless

Aardcore is right, there would be a bunch of wanna be ninjas on every server for two days before they realise, "Oh crap, they have GUNS!".

"Don't bring a knife to a gun fight" - the knife is a last resort, unless you're stat padding or going for you knife badge.

2007-08-04 14:22:08

#22

MAGUIRE93: High Angle Hell; +182|6455|Schofield Barracks

yes we should be able to throw knifes but then knife fights would be no fun
and we shoudl be able to kill with our wrenchs

2007-08-04 14:23:13

#23

RDMC: Enemy Wheelbarrow Spotted..!!; +736|6826|Area 51

Clear!
Allright your good to go, now get back to the forum.

2007-08-04 14:23:55

#24

M.O.A.B: 'Light 'em up!'; +1,220|6483|Escea

Darth_Rambo wrote:
madsmao wrote:
Knife throwing, wrench whacking and hand to hand combat in general would be sweet. Perhaps it would make the game to much of an infantry game though and that already seems to be a problem the way it is now.
Wrench whacking would be AWESOME!!! Good one!

You could tighten his nuts

2007-08-04 14:24:37

#25

stef10: Member; +173|6743|Denmark

lol, you just revived a topic that is over a year old!

you must be a superb medic!!!

BF2S Forums EA should make the Knife throwable!?

Bernadictus wrote:

Kung Jew wrote:

Bernadictus wrote:

Bernadictus wrote:

madsmao wrote:

Kaosdad008 wrote:

madsmao wrote:

sparklet wrote:

Darth_Rambo wrote:

madsmao wrote:

Aardcore wrote:

Darth_Rambo wrote:

madsmao wrote:

Board footer