madmurre
I suspect something is amiss
+117|7139|Sweden

ShowMeTheMonkey wrote:

If you want to read about a proper, proper SAS guy, you should SERIOUSLY read "The Shooting Gallery" by Gaz Hunter. One of my favourite books of all time.
He went
Green Jackets
SAS
Mecenary in Afghanistan
Back in SAS (At the same rank as he went in ONLY PERSON EVER to do this)

It's seriously that good:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/5 … AA240_.jpg
Thanks for the Tip i could recommend "Ghost Force" by Ken Connor in return. You get allot of history and are shown the politics behind the scenes.

Besides that Gunslinger said it before, there´s no point ranking todays SF:s we don´t know. And i´m willing to bet they all have the same physical training basicly so no differences here. Not to forget we are not told when they do a sucessful mission only the failures reach our ears. ( mostly )

Delta got allot of shit after some of theirs so called failures but they were´nt to blame there were also major fuck ups on a higher level. To do a good job you must have the oppurtunity to do so.
M.O.A.B
'Light 'em up!'
+1,220|6651|Escea

FEOS wrote:

M.O.A.B wrote:

I've got a book about different Special Forces groups around the world, SAS, Delta, SEAL's, GSG-9, GIGN etc. But it also lists the Royal Marines, which I can see as they are classed as commandos. But also the USMC is classed as a special forces group in this book, I didn't know it was.
I believe your book is mistaken. While there are some units in the USMC considered "special ops capable" (SOC), there are no designated USMC SOF ...yet. Force Recon is the closest they have to SOF, but they are still considered SOC USMC units, not dedicated SOF.
Always thought it didn't seem right.

madmurre wrote:

ShowMeTheMonkey wrote:

If you want to read about a proper, proper SAS guy, you should SERIOUSLY read "The Shooting Gallery" by Gaz Hunter. One of my favourite books of all time.
He went
Green Jackets
SAS
Mecenary in Afghanistan
Back in SAS (At the same rank as he went in ONLY PERSON EVER to do this)

It's seriously that good:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/5 … AA240_.jpg
Thanks for the Tip i could recommend "Ghost Force" by Ken Connor in return. You get allot of history and are shown the politics behind the scenes.

Besides that Gunslinger said it before, there´s no point ranking todays SF:s we don´t know. And i´m willing to bet they all have the same physical training basicly so no differences here. Not to forget we are not told when they do a sucessful mission only the failures reach our ears. ( mostly )

Delta got allot of shit after some of theirs so called failures but they were´nt to blame there were also major fuck ups on a higher level. To do a good job you must have the oppurtunity to do so.
The Iran mission also had the odds against them, bad weather, problems with the aircraft and stuff. But all special forces groups have had their bad moments. During the Falklands it was either the SAS or SBS that got into a blue on blue firefight with British Paras in the dark.

Last edited by M.O.A.B (2008-02-11 06:09:41)

B.Schuss
I'm back, baby... ( sort of )
+664|7270|Cologne, Germany

as has been said, pretty useless to compare different Spec Op Forces.

As fas training is concerned, most active western Spec Op Forces are probably equal ( SAS, german KSK, Navy Seals, Deltas, Sajeret Matkal, etc ), but some have an edge as far as experience is concerned, simply because they have been involved in more operations.

As far as the KSK is concerned, I believe they have performed well alongside their american and british counterparts in Afghanistan.
The_Guardsman
Tally Ho!!
+81|7173|I'm not sure.... Buts its dark

M.O.A.B wrote:

The Iran mission also had the odds against them, bad weather, problems with the aircraft and stuff. But all special forces groups have had their bad moments. During the Falklands it was either the SAS or SBS that got into a blue on blue firefight with British Paras in the dark.
It apparently was an SAS blue on blue with an SBS patrol. No fucker informed either part that other chaps were in the area. Thats nothing a Chinook full of Paras almost got blown to kingdom come by an Artillery mission because the head shed did'nt inform them that they were using Chinook lifts up the mountain. Fortunatly someone saw the markings on the Chinook and radioed through to stop the fire mission.

For those that read SAS books l recommend that you take them with a pinch of salt at times. Some of it can be far fetched or embilished. I do recommend that you read a book called Daggers Drawn. It charts there earlier sucsess during WW II.

Oh on a completely different note l've just watched Rambo 4. Good film, but why the fuck did they make the SAS bod a chopper??? I've watched a few documentrys with SAS blokes in and they come across as down to earth blokes. Not complete throbbers!!
M.O.A.B
'Light 'em up!'
+1,220|6651|Escea

The_Guardsman wrote:

M.O.A.B wrote:

The Iran mission also had the odds against them, bad weather, problems with the aircraft and stuff. But all special forces groups have had their bad moments. During the Falklands it was either the SAS or SBS that got into a blue on blue firefight with British Paras in the dark.
It apparently was an SAS blue on blue with an SBS patrol. No fucker informed either part that other chaps were in the area. Thats nothing a Chinook full of Paras almost got blown to kingdom come by an Artillery mission because the head shed did'nt inform them that they were using Chinook lifts up the mountain. Fortunatly someone saw the markings on the Chinook and radioed through to stop the fire mission.

For those that read SAS books l recommend that you take them with a pinch of salt at times. Some of it can be far fetched or embilished. I do recommend that you read a book called Daggers Drawn. It charts there earlier sucsess during WW II.

Oh on a completely different note l've just watched Rambo 4. Good film, but why the fuck did they make the SAS bod a chopper??? I've watched a few documentrys with SAS blokes in and they come across as down to earth blokes. Not complete throbbers!!
Depends whether or not he was a Rupert . But I know what you mean, lots of SAS I've seen are down to earth guys.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard