Poll

Which is more likely to lead to alcoholism?

Binge drinking on the weekend50%50% - 55
Casually drinking at home on a regular/semi-reg basis50%50% - 55
Total: 110
CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|7002
Following a disagreement in the house last night I'd like to put this to the general populace:

I contend that casually drinking alcohol (invariably wine) in small-ish quantities in the home over meals/in front of the TV leads to a greater risk of developing alcoholism than going on the batter on a Friday or Saturday night, perhaps drinking as many as 15 pints of beer.

Do you agree or disagree? Which carries the higher risk of leading to alcoholism?

Last edited by CameronPoe (2007-06-06 04:29:23)

wachtler83
Member
+22|7032|Columbus,Ohio
i think regular drinking because it will become part of your daily habit and daily habits are hard to break imo
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7204|Argentina
Of course, regular drinking.  Before getting married, I used to drink on the weekends with my friends, mostly beer and champagne.  I used to drink a lot on Fridays and Saturdays nights, and that never led to alcoholism.  It was social drinking.  Now, I only drink Coke.
joker3327
=IBF2=
+305|7045|Cheshire. UK
I dont think either of them lead to alcoholism  there are always different circumstances or reasons why people become alcoholic
JahManRed
wank
+646|7074|IRELAND

Regular drinking.
Ive seen too many people start with a glass of wine with dinner to a glass after. Prity soon they get used to the feeling of being full of food and tired with the lift of the booze to lift them out of it. Then you keep going. Once you are over 3 glasses of wine you have to keep going or a hangover kicks in within an hour or so. I know couples who don't talk to each other, then get some wine in and they are all over each other. Prity soon they need the booze to make their relationship work. sad really.
Ty
Mass Media Casualty
+2,398|7221|Noizyland

Neither. Depends on the person.
The only thing that really separates them is the regularity factor. Drinks once or twice a week don't suggest alcoholism which is being reliant on alcohol. However every night, (or therabouts,) having a drink would suggest that there is more reliance on a continual flow of alcohol.

I'll side with you on this one I think. Alcoholism is relying on alcohol, not necessarily drinking a lot of it in one go.
[Blinking eyes thing]
Steam: http://steamcommunity.com/id/tzyon
Plisken
POE2 Addict For Life
+21|7030|Vic, Australia
I personally believe alcoholism isn't as effected by the options as much if you were allowed alcohol when you were younger (early teens sometimes younger).
I live in an Italian style family and I was introduced early to wine, I'm now 16 and alcohol doesn't interest me, my mates on the other hand crave to go out drinking. Though I might be the exception not the rule. I believe people are attracted to what you can't have, and if you were told your not allowed a beer or similar till your 18 (or 21 depending on where you live), your gonna try and break that by sneaking out with ya friends and go drinking with them, which could lead to dangerous situations, while if you with your family when you drank, you would be looked after more and it also stops you from over drinking and getting alcohol poisoning etc. If you  go drinking with your friends your gonna go out regularly and binge, and if that continues your gonna get an alcohol dependence.

Last edited by Plisken (2007-06-06 04:57:41)

Braddock
Agitator
+916|6736|Éire
I used to binge at weekends but don't go out as much as I used to and find myself having the odd beer or two during the week now and definitely feel that you could easily slip into a habit doing so. I feel you would definitely be more at risk of developing a beer belly with sporadic drinking as opposed to binge drinking.
RedTwizzler
I do it for the lulz.
+124|6983|Chicago
Daily drinking. You (the person in the situation, that is) will start off drinking while watching TV or playing a rousing session of BF2, and eventually you will begin to mentally equate use of the TV or playing BF2 with drinking. That leads to equating more things to drinking, as you drink more and more while doing everyday tasks.
jsnipy
...
+3,277|6969|...

I chose "Casually drinking at home on a regular/semi-reg basis"

I'm not sure one would be more signifigant than the other (in my educated experience) ...
My father and father's father were both alcoholics, I know my father when he drank was more of a day to day drinker.

I don't think getting pissed on the weekends is any worse.

Of course it all boils down to why you drink.

Last edited by jsnipy (2007-06-06 04:59:20)

RedTwizzler
I do it for the lulz.
+124|6983|Chicago

Ty wrote:

I'll side with you on this one I think. Alcoholism is relying on alcohol, not necessarily drinking a lot of it in one go.
True, but, just for the sake of argument, couldn't you say that regularly binging on weekends is a reliance on alcohol?

Last edited by RedTwizzler (2007-06-06 04:59:12)

Plisken
POE2 Addict For Life
+21|7030|Vic, Australia
Now that I think about it. Binge drinking every weekend is regular consumption because you drink it regularly every weekend. If ya know what I mean?

jsnipy wrote:

Of course it all boils down to why you drink.
I agree with Jsnipy.  It ultimately boils down to why...

Last edited by Plisken (2007-06-06 05:08:19)

Switch
Knee Deep In Clunge
+489|6910|Tyne & Wear, England
The latter is true, absolutely.  I go out Friday and Saturday and those are my nights to get well and truly trolleyed, but I can confidently say that I would never become an alcoholic because of it.  However I never drink in the home during the week, it just doesn't appeal to me.

I believe that the vast majority of alcoholism comes from people regularly drinking in the home.
Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known.
BVC
Member
+325|7142
Alcoholism is reliance/dependency on alcohol.  For some it takes the form of getting pissed all weekend, and for many others it takes the form of one or two regular drinks most nights of the week.

Please try to ignore my sig/clan for this thread.

Last edited by Pubic (2007-06-06 05:40:08)

ATG
Banned
+5,233|6975|Global Command
I'm everyday drinker, but almost never get drunk.

Before you know it alcoholism is you. Be careful.
buttersIRL
Member
+17|7044
i think it depends on the reason you're drinking, If you regularly binge drinking at the weeks because you need a way to escape from your regular life then that could lead more to a dependency on alcohol than drinking a few during the week.

I shared a house with 5 people and we would regularly drink during the week, watching football or DVD's having a few tinnies or a bottle of wine.  Then at the weekends I'd go out and binge drink with my mates and get totally wasted (and then become very supseptible to the drugs people where offering me ! ) 

I don't drink much anymore because i was/am on the way to becoming an alcoholic, but when I go out at weekends I feel the urge to get wasted much more that I miss drinking during the week.
oug
Calmer than you are.
+380|6965|Πάϊ
I don't like to drink alone. But when I'm out with friends, it's like all we do. I guess the problem starts when you're home alone watching tv and instead of coke you drink vodka.
ƒ³
lyonsie99
Member
+0|6617
Binge drinking and casual drinking both provide increased risks of alcoholism to those already at risk of developing problems. Individuals with  family history of alcoholism, specific genetic make up, psychological and/or psychiatric problems are more likely to alcohol problems no matter what the drinking pattern.
superfly_cox
soup fly mod
+717|7228

from what i understand alcoholics are different physiologically than non-alcoholics from a genetic point of view.  they react differently to alcohol and develop a dependence on it which is different than normal people.

you can be a sober and still be an alcoholic because when you take that drink you'll quickly lose yourself in the alcohol.  at the same time you can be a problem drinker who is not an alcoholic.
tthf
Member 5307
+210|7204|06-01
i have developed a belly at the age of 30 (turning 31) from almost daily drinking...
not copious amounts but a pint ater dinner or a 2 glasses of wine...
i gotta start exercising again...
T.Pike
99 Problems . . .
+187|6729|Pennsyltucky

CameronPoe wrote:

Following a disagreement in the house last night I'd like to put this to the general populace:

I contend that casually drinking alcohol (invariably wine) in small-ish quantities in the home over meals/in front of the TV leads to a greater risk of developing alcoholism than going on the batter on a Friday or Saturday night, perhaps drinking as many as 15 pints of beer.

Do you agree or disagree? Which carries the higher risk of leading to alcoholism?
Wow, great idea for a post.

I voted for Binge Drinking, but I'm really torn between the two.

I grew up with both parents drinking on a daily basis. Not a "casual drink on the weekends, on the weekends they ramped it up though.

I'm going to have to put a little more thought into this subject.
ghettoperson
Member
+1,943|7095

superfly_cox wrote:

from what i understand alcoholics are different physiologically than non-alcoholics from a genetic point of view.  they react differently to alcohol and develop a dependence on it which is different than normal people.

you can be a sober and still be an alcoholic because when you take that drink you'll quickly lose yourself in the alcohol.  at the same time you can be a problem drinker who is not an alcoholic.
Yeah, that's also true.

I have to say though, out of the two I think the regular drinking. I do both, I go out for a large quantity of beers with my amigos on weekends, but then I also like to have the odd beer during the week. I like my beer.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|7212|UK
Regular drinking makes your body become more used to alcohol, it means you have alcohol in your system nearly the whole time, thus forms a dependency. Seems quite simple to me.
chittydog
less busy
+586|7281|Kubra, Damn it!

Plisken wrote:

Now that I think about it. Binge drinking every weekend is regular consumption because you drink it regularly every weekend. If ya know what I mean?
So if I only drink once each year on New Year's Eve am I a regular drinker and in danger of developing a dependency?
Hurricane
Banned
+1,153|7077|Washington, DC

One small glass of red wine is probably not going to form a habit, depending on the individual. Some people are likely more prone to developing a habit than others.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard