my take
Wireless speeds. Att's edge is slow. Fail
Length of contract and no discount on price? Fail
Special version of youTube, not actual youtube? Fail (not i dont even use youtube that much, but they advertise something that isnt what people think it is.)
It Snazzy. Win
Lack of 3rd party apps. Fail
Glass screen. On the fence. I don't have an iPod so I dont know how those last.
Max 8gb HD. Win. heh, more than I have on my ipaq 6315.
Its an apple product. Fail. I hate mac Fanboys more than the erosion of the US constitution.
Its an apple product. Win. They make some nice looking stuff.
No keyboard. Win. Im used to this already.
Dual touch screen. Win. Useful.
Dual touch screen + oily hands. Fail.
Safari Browser. Don't know. never used.
And that is my take on the iphone. I wont be buying one mainly because it forces me to use itunes (the last i heard) its locked to at&t which sucks. and they are being quite gimmicky with some of the features with too many gotchas. Ipaq 6315, your my only (smartphone) friend.