Instant-death for TK's

2006-01-30 14:00:56

#1

BigHaarpoon: Member; +0|7099|Berlin, Germany

Hy Mates,

how would you guys (and maybe girls ) think about that punishing someone for a TK causes the instant death of the one who TKed.
I think so the killing for vehicles would have finaly an end!
I really hate this pricks!

Would be nice to hear your opinion.
CY on the BF

Last edited by BigHaarpoon (2006-01-30 15:41:57)

2006-01-30 18:17:09

#2

CrazeD: Member; +368|7109|Maine

That'd be funny.. wait till they take off, then punish them haha.

Last edited by CrazeD (2006-01-30 18:17:31)

2006-01-30 18:24:00

#3

Mabec: Re-Member-Me; +6|7268

Actually.. yeah, why not... then again, what about ALL the "misstakes" everyone seems to do... o_O
Or all the kamikaze guys that jumps infront of your car?

2006-01-30 18:24:26

#4

-(PK)-DarkIllusion: Member; +1|7277

than every1 would be punishing even if they're accidents. you know that there are people out there with their finger on the page down button 24/7...and press it no matter what...

2006-01-30 21:46:52

#5

SlowReload: Member; +0|7098

it could be an option. you could forgive, you could punish or u could kill the tker

2006-01-30 21:53:21

#6

Gawwad: My way or Haddaway!; +212|7121|Espoo, Finland

SlowReload wrote:
it could be an option. you could forgive, you could punish or u could kill the tker

http://www.bf2player.com/sig/44772099-539.png

It could not be an option in the 12 year old community of BF2...

2006-01-30 22:39:07

#7

7thEs_ChibiKrillin: Member; +3|7100

What happens when you get in the jet first and the other guy jumps infront of you causing you to TK him? He punishes/kills you and now you have 2 tickets gone from your side and an empty jet on the runway. Not a bad idea but to easy to abuse.

Last edited by 7thEs_ChibiKrillin (2006-01-30 22:39:24)

2006-01-31 10:34:16

#8

BigHaarpoon: Member; +0|7099|Berlin, Germany

hmm, didn't think this way.....

maybe i'm too good to have such evil thoughts

so we have to live with the stupid ones, damed.....

2006-01-31 10:41:20

#9

Cbass: Kick His Ass!; +371|7131|Howell, Mi USA

it's a good idea dude but i can see it really getting out of control.

https://bf3s.com/sigs/bb53a522780eff5b30ba3252d44932cc2f5b8c4f.png

2006-01-31 13:05:38

#10

Zukabazuka: Member; +23|7122

This should be enable when the person who tk has sniper kits and shoot other pilots, this would be better IMO.

This is really getting anoying about this double post, you admins should look in to this.

Last edited by Zukabazuka (2006-01-31 13:06:40)

2006-01-31 19:15:57

#11

Leonnoe1: Member; +2|7162

This would rock so hard when some idiot walks in front of your tank as you go to drive away.

No.

2006-02-11 21:10:26

#12

breethon: Member; +0|7086

BigHaarpoon wrote:
Hy Mates,

how would you guys (and maybe girls ) think about that punishing someone for a TK causes the instant death of the one who TKed.
I think so the killing for vehicles would have finaly an end!
I really hate this pricks!

Would be nice to hear your opinion.
CY on the BF

Tell me that you have never team killed? Ever saw one of your teammates with their name in red? That sux! Instant point loss x6. And don't forget who it was.....oh boy!

2006-02-11 21:19:15

#13

Mike_J: Member; +68|7106

they should do it like on half life 2 deathmatch- give you multiple options.

1. Make "player name" a time bomb
2. Set "player name" on fire
3. Put "player name" in slow mo

i've seen all kinds of things on different servers.

2006-02-11 21:27:36

#14

AuSFinN: Member; +1|7125

Hmm.. I disagree. It would have to depend on the severity of the teamkill. Some people punish for accidental teamkills such as mines or claymores, when its their own fault for running into a skull and crossbone.

After playing the game for such a large number of times, wouldn't you think they would figure out what the red skull and crossbone means?

It would make TK punish even worse. You would die because of someones own mistake.

Last edited by AuSFinN (2006-02-11 21:28:28)

2006-02-14 05:46:54

#15

lsof: Member; +0|7090

Punishment for team killing seems to be an absurdity to me - at least among real teams of soldiers, who would not TK unless it was accidental. There are just too many situations where team kills can happen. An Armor vs Armor fight, when someone on the team is too close but not noticed; I am confident the list of situations becomes long. There are apparent bugs in the game, where colors don't pop up upon mouseover; the red bug thing, and who knows what other buggy game behavior contributes.

I believe there are examples of when intentional team killing can be justified in this game. If a Spec Ops can take out a vehicle full of troops but a nearby team member get killed, then the team comes out ahead. Similar examples for an Engineer can occur. A tank once rolled into our home base and paused, so I ran up behind it, dropped an AT mine, and then one in the front, then ran for cover. When I looked up, the driver had jumped out and a team mate jumped in and attempted to drive off.

The pusnishment system does not resolve the issues. One important point in this game is that it is not real, nor can it be totally realistic. Death is nothing but a thing in this game, and a thing that happens every minute; there is no sussessful fighting going if there is no death occurring. If team killing is so unacceptable in the game, then turn team damage off - that seems to be the only comperable solution I've seen so far.

For what it is worth, I always forgive the team killer. Always. If I judge I'm getting intentionally TK'd, I forgive, and leave the server.

2006-02-16 11:19:06

#16

bf2_zspyvin: Member; +17|7121|The Netherlands

LOL this is the dumbest idea i ever saw on this forum

2006-02-17 02:59:17

#17

Chillay-14: Member; +21|7115

yer id lyk that idea alot but also u shoudnt get a death point when ur tked

2006-02-18 16:04:10

#18

Sh4rkb1t3: Member; +6|7121

No way. Some people re-map the punish key to the left mouse button.

2006-02-18 16:09:40

#19

Ty: Mass Media Casualty; +2,398|7211|Noizyland

Those angry crybabies who know it was their fault they got killed, (pre-patch Claymores and AT mines,) would kill all the time. It would be a mess.

[Blinking eyes thing]
Steam: http://steamcommunity.com/id/tzyon

2006-02-18 17:35:28

#20

twood375: Member; +16|7085|Washington, D.C.

hahaha sounds like those crazy cs servers where you get 10 options of what to do to the TKers

1. Instant death
2. Light on fire
3. Give drugs
4. Slow-mo
5. Blind
6. Freeze
7. Invert
8. Lose all cash
9. Bend over for spanking
10. Death by anal horse fucking

2006-02-18 17:42:58

#21

Lucien: Fantasma Parastasie; +1,451|7090

lol twood, you forgot these: (real examples)

1: Turn into a chicken
2: Turn into a rocket
3: Turn into a bomb (run teammates, run!)
4: Freeze the player, remove all weapons
5: Continously slap player around for 30 seconds

2006-02-19 01:51:03

#22

123456789: Member; +1|7100

lsof wrote:
Punishment for team killing seems to be an absurdity to me - at least among real teams of soldiers, who would not TK unless it was accidental. There are just too many situations where team kills can happen. An Armor vs Armor fight, when someone on the team is too close but not noticed; I am confident the list of situations becomes long. There are apparent bugs in the game, where colors don't pop up upon mouseover; the red bug thing, and who knows what other buggy game behavior contributes.

I believe there are examples of when intentional team killing can be justified in this game. If a Spec Ops can take out a vehicle full of troops but a nearby team member get killed, then the team comes out ahead. Similar examples for an Engineer can occur. A tank once rolled into our home base and paused, so I ran up behind it, dropped an AT mine, and then one in the front, then ran for cover. When I looked up, the driver had jumped out and a team mate jumped in and attempted to drive off.

The pusnishment system does not resolve the issues. One important point in this game is that it is not real, nor can it be totally realistic. Death is nothing but a thing in this game, and a thing that happens every minute; there is no sussessful fighting going if there is no death occurring. If team killing is so unacceptable in the game, then turn team damage off - that seems to be the only comperable solution I've seen so far.

For what it is worth, I always forgive the team killer. Always. If I judge I'm getting intentionally TK'd, I forgive, and leave the server.

I agree with you except for the last bit. If you can, report the TK'r to an admin.

I think a better solution would be to take out the punish option and just make it an automatic kick and 24 hour ban once you commit X number of TK's in a round. This would cause people to be more careful knowing that kick is on the way. Granted there will be accidents and there will be noobs and jackasses that are going to jump in front of your vehicle and drive over your mines, but it is just a 24 hour ban. No biggie.

One other thing. Have a way for the server to keep track of the TK bans. That way an admin can see that a particular player is constantly getting banned and make the ban permanent.

Last edited by 123456789 (2006-02-19 01:56:29)

BF2S Forums Instant-death for TK's

SlowReload wrote:

BigHaarpoon wrote:

lsof wrote:

Board footer