usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

I know most of you are not in the aviation industry.  But for years and years pilots grabbed whatever they wanted out of the galley and stuck it up against the left or right rear flight deck window.   It is an amazing natural refrigerator.  One airline for the sake of cost saving decided to put an end to that practice.

Essentially, if you want bottled water, buy and bring your own.  Simple concept for most of us of course.   But, apparently all the old airline pilots have a problem with this.  They start bitching about dehydration.  The that some are fighting for free water is disturbing.

So I have to ask:

Am I the only one who thinks that "Bring your own fucking water" is too much to ask?

Spark
liquid fluoride thorium reactor
+874|7103|Canberra, AUS
Wha?!

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that? Or does it cost maintenance money every time the window is touched?

But yes, they should bring their own water. They ain't children.

Last edited by Spark (2008-02-09 23:27:20)

The paradox is only a conflict between reality and your feeling what reality ought to be.
~ Richard Feynman
Flaming_Maniac
prince of insufficient light
+2,490|7135|67.222.138.85
Damn communist airline pilots. They need to learn to get with the capitalism or get the fuck out.
Reciprocity
Member
+721|7009|the dank(super) side of Oregon
most people arent happy unless they're bitching about something.  for well paid pilots it comes down to bottled water.
SenorToenails
Veritas et Scientia
+444|6559|North Tonawanda, NY

Spark wrote:

Wha?!

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that? Or does it cost maintenance money every time the window is touched?

But yes, they should bring their own water. They ain't children.
The point is that they took the food and water from the airline galley.  Not that touching the window costs money.
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

Spark wrote:

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that?
Assume 40 cents per bottle.  Now factor 4 bottles per flight.  Factor that by 50 flights per day.  Then multiply that by 365 days.

Are we talking a shitload of money in the millions?  No.  But savings is what matters.

Last edited by usmarine (2008-02-09 23:35:29)

Spark
liquid fluoride thorium reactor
+874|7103|Canberra, AUS

usmarine wrote:

Spark wrote:

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that?
Assume 40 cents per bottle.  Now factor 4 bottles per flight.  Factor that by 50 flights per day.  Then multiply that by 365 days.

Are we talking a shitload of money in the millions?  No.  But savings is what matters.
Ah, now I get it.

Why the fuck don't they just grow up and bring their own water...

Where are you in the industry btw? Groundstaff, maintenance, or in-the-air?

Last edited by Spark (2008-02-09 23:43:24)

The paradox is only a conflict between reality and your feeling what reality ought to be.
~ Richard Feynman
Reciprocity
Member
+721|7009|the dank(super) side of Oregon

Spark wrote:

Ah, now I get it.

Why the fuck don't they just grow up and bring their own water...
if you had a god complex wouldn't you be upset about paying for water?
SenorToenails
Veritas et Scientia
+444|6559|North Tonawanda, NY

Spark wrote:

Why the fuck don't they just grow up and bring their own water...
I can see why they are bitching.  It might seem absurd, but a lot of places provide drinks for employees.  Office buildings have water coolers etc...

Although, why the pilots don't just buy a case every so often for their own flights, I don't know...
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

Spark wrote:

Where are you in the industry btw? Groundstaff, maintenance, or in-the-air?
Operations Supervisor. (Basically in charge while the head cheese sleep)

Last edited by usmarine (2008-02-09 23:50:31)

mikkel
Member
+383|7030

usmarine wrote:

Spark wrote:

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that?
Assume 40 cents per bottle.  Now factor 4 bottles per flight.  Factor that by 50 flights per day.  Then multiply that by 365 days.

Are we talking a shitload of money in the millions?  No.  But savings is what matters.
40 cents per bottle is way overestimated when these are bought in massive bulk. Bottled water probably has the highest mark-up of anything sold in a convenience store. I'd sooner estimate 4 cents per bottle.

To be honest, while I realise that the pilots earn more than enough to buy their own water, I also see why they'd complain about having to work in an environment where they sit for potentially many, many hours straight with no access to any water other than what they bring themselves. If I had to fly an aircraft and be in charge of the safety of hundreds of lives for many hours, I'd find it somewhat petty if the airline couldn't even afford me access to something as basic as a bottle of water.
nukchebi0
Пушкин, наше всё
+387|6752|New Haven, CT

mikkel wrote:

usmarine wrote:

Spark wrote:

How could you 'save costs' by eliminating that?
Assume 40 cents per bottle.  Now factor 4 bottles per flight.  Factor that by 50 flights per day.  Then multiply that by 365 days.

Are we talking a shitload of money in the millions?  No.  But savings is what matters.
40 cents per bottle is way overestimated when these are bought in massive bulk. Bottled water probably has the highest mark-up of anything sold in a convenience store. I'd sooner estimate 4 cents per bottle.

To be honest, while I realise that the pilots earn more than enough to buy their own water, I also see why they'd complain about having to work in an environment where they sit for potentially many, many hours straight with no access to any water other than what they bring themselves. If I had to fly an aircraft and be in charge of the safety of hundreds of lives for many hours, I'd find it somewhat petty if the airline couldn't even afford me access to something as basic as a bottle of water.
Yes...
Mekstizzle
WALKER
+3,611|7050|London, England

usmarine wrote:

Spark wrote:

Where are you in the industry btw? Groundstaff, maintenance, or in-the-air?
Operations Supervisor. (Basically in charge while the head cheese sleep)
Head Cheese is always asleep, and you're always flaming noobs on the internets. Great Success!

https://www.expedition360.com/journal/borat.jpg
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

mikkel wrote:

40 cents per bottle is way overestimated when these are bought in massive bulk. Bottled water probably has the highest mark-up of anything sold in a convenience store. I'd sooner estimate 4 cents per bottle.
Little lessen on aviation.  Everything is marked up severely.  Food and drinks have to be delivered to the plane in sealed containers.  Now add in the cost for Gate Gourmet to pay for the badges and other crap that goes along with working at an airport.  So yes, 40 cents a bottle is not overestimated.

edit:  For example, say a flight crew needed some more ice and it was not on the normal catering turn, it is a $120 call out just for ice.

Last edited by usmarine (2008-02-10 11:33:36)

mikkel
Member
+383|7030

usmarine wrote:

mikkel wrote:

40 cents per bottle is way overestimated when these are bought in massive bulk. Bottled water probably has the highest mark-up of anything sold in a convenience store. I'd sooner estimate 4 cents per bottle.
Little lessen on aviation.  Everything is marked up severely.  Food and drinks have to be delivered to the plane in sealed containers.  Now add in the cost for Gate Gourmet to pay for the badges and other crap that goes along with working at an airport.  So yes, 40 cents a bottle is not overestimated.

edit:  For example, say a flight crew needed some more ice and it was not on the normal catering turn, it is a $120 call out just for ice.
I'm well aware that there are a good deal of logistical hurdles when catering to civil aviation. The thing is, I haven't been on a flight yet where they ran out of water, and I really find it hard to believe that it happens on a majority of flights, so when these pilots are taking a bottle of water out of the fridge, the logistics are already paid for, and instead of wasting it, they're taking a bottle of water costing less than 10 cents. So what's the problem?
GorillaTicTacs
Member
+231|6802|Kyiv, Ukraine

usmarine wrote:

I know most of you are not in the aviation industry.  But for years and years pilots grabbed whatever they wanted out of the galley and stuck it up against the left or right rear flight deck window.   It is an amazing natural refrigerator.  One airline for the sake of cost saving decided to put an end to that practice.

Essentially, if you want bottled water, buy and bring your own.  Simple concept for most of us of course.   But, apparently all the old airline pilots have a problem with this.  They start bitching about dehydration.  The that some are fighting for free water is disturbing.

So I have to ask:

Am I the only one who thinks that "Bring your own fucking water" is too much to ask?
Says the former Marine...

An employer has the obligation to provide in some way for a worker's basic needs.  Access to water and restroom facilities being one of them.  If the airline wants, they can issue canteens or little cooler jugs to the pilots and require them to fill up before boarding each flight, just add an item to the pre-flight checklist ("Pilot canteen coolers are topped off with water").  Its not a black and white solution (bottled water or no water), both sides can give a little.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7186|Argentina
You forget that pilots are very underpaid people /sarcasm.
mikkel
Member
+383|7030

sergeriver wrote:

You forget that pilots are very underpaid people /sarcasm.
If you can afford to pay people high salaries, you can afford a few bottles of water. Of course they could buy their own, but the airlines could also supply basic necessities.

Last edited by mikkel (2008-02-11 10:43:32)

sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7186|Argentina

mikkel wrote:

sergeriver wrote:

You forget that pilots are very underpaid people /sarcasm.
If you can afford to pay people high salaries, you can afford a few bottles of water. Of course they could buy their own, but the airlines could also supply basic necessities.
Do you know that most airlines are losing money?  Why do you think they give you shit for meal?
Bertster7
Confused Pothead
+1,101|7010|SE London

It's a bit pathetic to complain about, but I can see where they're coming from.

Isn't it the responsibility of an employer to provide water to their employees anyway? In the UK you can get free water virtually anywhere, restaurants are legally obligated to give you water for free, even if you're not a customer - even fast food outlets like McDonalds, but since they often have no drinkable tap water you usually have to get ice from them.
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

GorillaTicTacs wrote:

An employer has the obligation to provide in some way for a worker's basic needs.  Access to water and restroom facilities being one of them.  If the airline wants, they can issue canteens or little cooler jugs to the pilots and require them to fill up before boarding each flight, just add an item to the pre-flight checklist ("Pilot canteen coolers are topped off with water").  Its not a black and white solution (bottled water or no water), both sides can give a little.
We did that.  We gave them nice little water bottles.  Now they are bitching about bacteria in the water bottles.....with no proof of course.  They apparently do not like that solution.  So, we provided them with the option.

Last edited by usmarine (2008-02-11 10:54:30)

Bertster7
Confused Pothead
+1,101|7010|SE London

usmarine wrote:

GorillaTicTacs wrote:

An employer has the obligation to provide in some way for a worker's basic needs.  Access to water and restroom facilities being one of them.  If the airline wants, they can issue canteens or little cooler jugs to the pilots and require them to fill up before boarding each flight, just add an item to the pre-flight checklist ("Pilot canteen coolers are topped off with water").  Its not a black and white solution (bottled water or no water), both sides can give a little.
We did that.  We gave them nice little water bottles.  Now they are bitching about bacteria in the water bottles.....with no proof of course.  They apparently do not like that solution.  So, we provided them with the option.
Fuck 'em then. You've offered them a perfectly valid solution. You only need provide them with clean safe drinking water, not fancy bottled water that costs 100x as much.
Dauntless
Admin
+2,249|7171|London

I don't think it's that big of a deal one way or the other.

The pilots have put a lot of their own money and time into the airline, a bottle of water per flight doesn't seem much to ask. I know they have a salary, but why argue over something like this? let them have it.
https://imgur.com/kXTNQ8D.png
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7190

Dauntless wrote:

I don't think it's that big of a deal one way or the other.

The pilots have put a lot of their own money and time into the airline, a bottle of water per flight doesn't seem much to ask. I know they have a salary, but why argue over something like this? let them have it.
What about the people who work on the ramp loading bags?  What about the crew scheduler?  Should they all get free bottled water then?
Bertster7
Confused Pothead
+1,101|7010|SE London

usmarine wrote:

Dauntless wrote:

I don't think it's that big of a deal one way or the other.

The pilots have put a lot of their own money and time into the airline, a bottle of water per flight doesn't seem much to ask. I know they have a salary, but why argue over something like this? let them have it.
What about the people who work on the ramp loading bags?  What about the crew scheduler?  Should they all get free bottled water then?
No. None of them should. They could probably employ another person to load the planes with the money they'd save on bottled water.

Last edited by Bertster7 (2008-02-11 11:16:01)

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard