Bell
Frosties > Cornflakes
+362|6824|UK

Not really technical per say, but am getting more and more complaints about Asus branded motherboards from customers (I build PC's as a bit on the side from time to time).  I'll tend to let the customer spec the machine them self (I'll recommend something if I think it is better but generally am not one to argue), and, the benchmarks and such online dont really tell the story of how equipment is to live with.  Yet, despite me being under the impression Asus are one of the premier brands in motherboards, there causing me quite a few headaches.

I've had Striker extreme 2's back

Maximus formula edtions

And everything between and under.  Out of my last ten builds, 7 have had asus boards, and out of that, I have replaced 4 them with a competitor board something like a month later on average, because of problems specific to them.

Apparantly the issue arose from the shift of production to china. 

Anyone else had problems?  Or is it just me

Martyn

Last edited by Bell (2008-03-13 11:16:09)

Gooners
Wiki Contributor
+2,700|6907

/slap

I was just looking at some new ASUS Mobos for a new rig.
Winston_Churchill
Bazinga!
+521|7014|Toronto | Canada

Yeah, my Striker Extreme drives me nuts, it doesn't boot up about 30% of the time and I've had it sent in for various repairs at least 3 times.
Gawwad
My way or Haddaway!
+212|6960|Espoo, Finland
Only thing that comes to mind are the fucked up BIOS versions. Haven't been able to overclock at all with any other BIOS except of the original.
I think I've had some other trouble aswell, but can't remember right now, hehe.
(P5N32-E SLI)
GC_PaNzerFIN
Work and study @ Technical Uni
+528|6689|Finland

Some Asus boards are piece of crap but some are the best of the best. Sometimes it isn't Asus's fault due to chipset related stuff.
The fact is Asus is the biggest motherboard manufacturer so it can be expected that there are more faulty boards from them than competitors in total  (more ppl complaining about them). I personally had quite many really bad Asus boards in the past (all had nforce chipset however) but my current Asus P5E X38 is awsome board. The nforce boards from Asus seem to be the most likely faulty ones compared to their Intel counterparts.

Asus nforce boards have shitty BIOS'es. Intel ones are awsome.

List of popular brand related issues:

DFI: Squealing and blowing up PWM. Dying boards.

Asus: Sometimes picky about ram and some BIOS problems (corrupt BIOS results in need of RMA).

Gigabyte: Dual boot (sometimes), DOA 

Abit: Dual boot

MSI: uh oh...

eVGA: Random BSOD/reboot.

Last edited by GC_PaNzerFIN (2008-03-13 11:46:10)

3930K | H100i | RIVF | 16GB DDR3 | GTX 480 | AX750 | 800D | 512GB SSD | 3TB HDD | Xonar DX | W8
Freezer7Pro
I don't come here a lot anymore.
+1,447|6472|Winland

GC_PaNzerFIN wrote:

Some Asus boards are piece of crap but some are the best of the best. Sometimes it isn't Asus's fault due to chipset related stuff.
The fact is Asus is the biggest motherboard manufacturer so it can be expected that there are more faulty boards from them than competitors in total  (more ppl complaining about them). I personally had quite many really bad Asus boards in the past (all had nforce chipset however) but my current Asus P5E X38 is awsome board. The nforce boards from Asus seem to be the most likely faulty ones compared to their Intel counterparts.

Asus nforce boards have shitty BIOS'es. Intel ones are awsome.

List of popular brand related issues:

DFI: Squealing and blowing up PWM. Dying boards.

Asus: Sometimes picky about ram and some BIOS problems (corrupt BIOS results in need of RMA).

Gigabyte: Dual boot (sometimes), DOA 

Abit: Dual boot

MSI: Everything

eVGA: Random BSOD/reboot.
fixed4u
The idea of any hi-fi system is to reproduce the source material as faithfully as possible, and to deliberately add distortion to everything you hear (due to amplifier deficiencies) because it sounds 'nice' is simply not high fidelity. If that is what you want to hear then there is no problem with that, but by adding so much additional material (by way of harmonics and intermodulation) you have a tailored sound system, not a hi-fi. - Rod Elliot, ESP
Dauntless
Admin
+2,249|7017|London

Freezer7Pro wrote:

GC_PaNzerFIN wrote:

Some Asus boards are piece of crap but some are the best of the best. Sometimes it isn't Asus's fault due to chipset related stuff.
The fact is Asus is the biggest motherboard manufacturer so it can be expected that there are more faulty boards from them than competitors in total  (more ppl complaining about them). I personally had quite many really bad Asus boards in the past (all had nforce chipset however) but my current Asus P5E X38 is awsome board. The nforce boards from Asus seem to be the most likely faulty ones compared to their Intel counterparts.

Asus nforce boards have shitty BIOS'es. Intel ones are awsome.

List of popular brand related issues:

DFI: Squealing and blowing up PWM. Dying boards.

Asus: Sometimes picky about ram and some BIOS problems (corrupt BIOS results in need of RMA).

Gigabyte: Dual boot (sometimes), DOA 

Abit: Dual boot

MSI: Everything

eVGA: Random BSOD/reboot.
fixed4u
What did you even change?
https://imgur.com/kXTNQ8D.png
Gawwad
My way or Haddaway!
+212|6960|Espoo, Finland

Dauntless wrote:

Freezer7Pro wrote:

GC_PaNzerFIN wrote:

Some Asus boards are piece of crap but some are the best of the best. Sometimes it isn't Asus's fault due to chipset related stuff.
The fact is Asus is the biggest motherboard manufacturer so it can be expected that there are more faulty boards from them than competitors in total  (more ppl complaining about them). I personally had quite many really bad Asus boards in the past (all had nforce chipset however) but my current Asus P5E X38 is awsome board. The nforce boards from Asus seem to be the most likely faulty ones compared to their Intel counterparts.

Asus nforce boards have shitty BIOS'es. Intel ones are awsome.

List of popular brand related issues:

DFI: Squealing and blowing up PWM. Dying boards.

Asus: Sometimes picky about ram and some BIOS problems (corrupt BIOS results in need of RMA).

Gigabyte: Dual boot (sometimes), DOA 

Abit: Dual boot

MSI: Everything

eVGA: Random BSOD/reboot.
fixed4u
What did you even change?
_NL_Lt.EngineerFox
Big Mouth Prick
+219|6805|Golf 1.8 GTI Wolfsburg Edition
First time on an ASUS board, never have had a problem with it.
CodePhoeniX
Member
+13|6490|USA

GC_PaNzerFIN wrote:

Some Asus boards are piece of crap but some are the best of the best. Sometimes it isn't Asus's fault due to chipset related stuff.
The fact is Asus is the biggest motherboard manufacturer so it can be expected that there are more faulty boards from them than competitors in total  (more ppl complaining about them). I personally had quite many really bad Asus boards in the past (all had nforce chipset however) but my current Asus P5E X38 is awsome board. The nforce boards from Asus seem to be the most likely faulty ones compared to their Intel counterparts.

Asus nforce boards have shitty BIOS'es. Intel ones are awsome.

List of popular brand related issues:

DFI: Squealing and blowing up PWM. Dying boards.

Asus: Sometimes picky about ram and some BIOS problems (corrupt BIOS results in need of RMA).

Gigabyte: Dual boot (sometimes), DOA 

Abit: Dual boot

MSI: Everything

eVGA: Random BSOD/reboot.
fixed4u

Hint: The change is in bold.

Last edited by CodePhoeniX (2008-03-13 20:53:37)

Overdose
Member
+13|6389|Fort Worth, TX
i have a asus p5e too. its nice and fast, but only one problem sometimes i get a reading of the cpu temp to be 1°C. idk if i should risk updating Bios and get a corrupted board.
.Sup
be nice
+2,646|6728|The Twilight Zone

Overdose wrote:

i have a asus p5e too. its nice and fast, but only one problem sometimes i get a reading of the cpu temp to be 1°C. idk if i should risk updating Bios and get a corrupted board.
Do you have a 45nm processor?
https://www.shrani.si/f/3H/7h/45GTw71U/untitled-1.png
GC_PaNzerFIN
Work and study @ Technical Uni
+528|6689|Finland

.Sup wrote:

Overdose wrote:

i have a asus p5e too. its nice and fast, but only one problem sometimes i get a reading of the cpu temp to be 1°C. idk if i should risk updating Bios and get a corrupted board.
Do you have a 45nm processor?
You pretty much can't corrupt BIOS if you use USB memory stick for flashing. Don't use the Windows tool Asus Update. That corrupts BIOS'es permanently. My CPU temps showed up normally with the stock BIOS but with this newer one it is like -20c from normal.
3930K | H100i | RIVF | 16GB DDR3 | GTX 480 | AX750 | 800D | 512GB SSD | 3TB HDD | Xonar DX | W8
Gooners
Wiki Contributor
+2,700|6907

I need to buy a crossfire ready Mobo, but which one!? Are the Maximus Formula editions that bad?
JaMrulezass
Member
+47|6739|Hong Kong
Watch maxishine's new video, the one with the XFX 780i board, he explains how we should stay away from ASUS boards coz they moved thier manufactering line to China.
GC_PaNzerFIN
Work and study @ Technical Uni
+528|6689|Finland

Gooners wrote:

I need to buy a crossfire ready Mobo, but which one!? Are the Maximus Formula editions that bad?
I recommend Asus P5E X38. Pure kickass.
3930K | H100i | RIVF | 16GB DDR3 | GTX 480 | AX750 | 800D | 512GB SSD | 3TB HDD | Xonar DX | W8

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard