stratozyck
Member
+35|7058
I would like to see what people think of this incident that resulted in the death of a friend of a friend.  Heres the facebook link, http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2 … amp;ref=nf , and heres the text of the summary copied and pasted.  Also, here is an online petition we're trying to get around:  http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/jus … swamy.html


Kapali Giridhar Swamy, 27, was killed November 18, 2007. He was punched in the face by Christopher Brett Pennington, and he died within moments in the middle of a Cullman, Alabama street.

The details of the events leading to the crime are as follows. Three individuals—Kapali Swamy, Gina Gonzalez, and Christopher Brett Pennington were driving to Pennington's residence shortly after 6am on 11/18; Kapali was kindly giving Pennington a ride home from a night out in Birmingham. Apparently, during the drive and after stopping the car, Kapali and Gina became involved in a heated verbal argument. Once they exited the car the argument continued, at which time Pennington approached Kapali. Words were exchanged, and then Pennington escalated a verbal confrontation to a physical one by punching Kapali. Kapali fell to the ground and was found to be pulseless and without any signs of life when emergency medical personnel arrived a few minutes later. Pennington's right fist was bruised, but his body was without any other signs of an altercation. Gina and a third party witness both assert that Kapali did not touch either Pennington or Gina.

The evidence of the case is as follows:
1) The alleged perpetrator fully confessed to punching Kapali in his statement to police.
2) Two independent eye-witnesses gave consistent descriptions of the events surrounding his death, directly implicating Pennington as the responsible party
3) These witnesses confirmed that Kapali did not initiate any physical conflict
4) The autopsy confirmed the cause of Kapali's death as massive brain hemorrhage and brainstem herniation, the direct result of "homicide."

Yet in January of 2008, a Cullman, Alabama grand jury inexplicably decided -- in a closed hearing -- not to indict Pennington on any charge which included involuntary manslaughter (a felony) and criminally negligent homicide (a misdemeanor). Basically the Grand Jury decided there was no need for a trial since in their eyes no crime was committed. Therefore Brett will not stand trial for his actions and thus a killer walks free.

Last edited by stratozyck (2008-04-03 14:42:43)

S.Lythberg
Mastermind
+429|6873|Chicago, IL
I think there's some Information missing, Jurors won't usually let a man walk unless they have good reason to do so.
Lotta_Drool
Spit
+350|6610|Ireland
I assume the Jury has much more info than me and made the correct decision.  Not sure what all you left out but it sounds unintentional and a tragedy. 

Now, if the guy who punched him was a Muslim on the other hand.......  <--- Soley added for the benifit of Konfusion.
Mitch
16 more years
+877|6952|South Florida
Swamy didn't mean to kill the guy, it was an accident. Im sure he's horribly sorry. Chances are he ain't a killer, just a dude who got heated.
15 more years! 15 more years!
HurricaИe
Banned
+877|6388|Washington DC

Mitch wrote:

Swamy didn't mean to kill the guy, it was an accident. Im sure he's horribly sorry. Chances are he ain't a killer, just a dude who got heated.
Swamy is the one who got killed.

And do you really want a guy who "gets heated" and ends up killing people to roam the streets? The VA Tech shooter "got heated."

Throw him in a fucking institution.
ATG
Banned
+5,233|6956|Global Command

Mitch wrote:


Christopher
didn't mean to kill the guy, it was an accident. Im sure he's horribly sorry. Chances are he ain't a killer, just a dude who got heated.
QFE

you gotta be aware that if you choose to enter into a fight you may not survive it.
Turquoise
O Canada
+1,596|6832|North Carolina

HurricaИe wrote:

Throw him in a fucking institution.
either that...  or "punch" him with a sledgehammer
RAIMIUS
You with the face!
+244|7141|US
I don't think a homicide charge would be appropriate.  I don't see any intent to kill, in that story.
Some sort of assault charges, or possibly a manslaughter count, would seem appropriate.
KEN-JENNINGS
I am all that is MOD!
+2,991|7058|949

ATG wrote:

Mitch wrote:


Christopher
didn't mean to kill the guy, it was an accident. Im sure he's horribly sorry. Chances are he ain't a killer, just a dude who got heated.
QFE

you gotta be aware that if you choose to enter into a fight you may not survive it.
He didn't enter a fight, unless you classify a "verbal confrontation" as a fight.  He was arguing, then got punched in the face.

At the very least, an assault with grave bodily injury.  Involuntary manslaughter would be more acceptable from the simple story he posted.  I could see no way in hell the Grand Jury would let the person off with no crime with the story you gave us.  There has to be more to it.
Turquoise
O Canada
+1,596|6832|North Carolina
Ken, this is Alabama we're talking about.  Anything is possible.
Vilham
Say wat!?
+580|7193|UK
It doesnt matter if the man died or not, what matters was that it was just a punch, the man didnt mean to kill the other man and it therefore cant be seen as murder. Simple as.


Not sure why it wasnt seen as man slaughter though. But tbh lots of people who commit man slaughter dont go to jail. Thats the whole point, its an accident.

Last edited by Vilham (2008-04-04 09:00:47)

ATG
Banned
+5,233|6956|Global Command
Involuntary manslaughter then.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard