Kmar
Truth is my Bitch
+5,695|7027|132 and Bush

Democrats who oppose the bill do so on behalf of their friends in Big Labor, not out of friendship for the Colombians. They claim that Alvaro Uribe has not done enough to end the violence against unionists in Colombia. Yet during the last six years, murders have decreased by over 40% in all categories, and by 86% against unionists.

The government conducted serious reforms during that period. Uribe helped rewrite the entire justice system, transforming it to a more modern system. As a result, they have won 156 convictions in crimes against trade unionists, when they only had one in the entire ten years that preceded 2002. The backlog of prosecutions in these crimes has dropped from six years to less than 18 months, and is still improving.

Opponents of the pact in the US, which exploits the murder of a trade unionist to argue against the pact’s ratification. What they don’t mention is that Jairo Giraldo Rey supported the free-trade pact before his murder, and was joined by 75 unions in Colombia in that position.

Jairo Giraldo Rey’s murder near Cali last November gave big labor a seemingly textbook case for why Congress should reject the Colombia free-trade pact, which President Bush sent to Congress Monday, forcing a vote on the contentious deal within 90 days.

    The 35-year-old union leader’s death showed why “the AFL-CIO remains unalterably opposed to passage of the U.S.-Colombia Free Trade Agreement,” wrote AFL-CIO President John Sweeney in a Nov. 8 letter to House and Senate members.

    The only problem is, Giraldo supported free trade.

    Indeed, his fellow members of Sinaltraifrut, a 10,000-member banana harvester’s union, say trade creates jobs and breaks up vested oligarchies. Whoever killed Giraldo likely didn’t want him flying to Washington that week to lobby Congress to pass the pact.
http://www.ibdeditorials.com/IBDArticle … 0600468367

Not all of the unions in Colombia support free trade, but it’s worth noting which unions do support it. Showalter reports that the majority of the private-sector unions want the pact approved, while the overwhelming number of public-sector unions oppose it. Because 70% of public-sector jobs are unionized as opposed to only 4.5% in the private sector, the public-sector unions in Colombia have a greater voice. However, the private sector unions understand that untariffed trade creates private-sector jobs and reduces the need for nanny-state positions on which the unions rely.
Xbone Stormsurgezz
ATG
Banned
+5,233|6955|Global Command
Nafta.

Wasn't that a Bush 1 thing?


Weird. One major thing wrecking our economy is the trade imbalance of which NAFTA plays a big part.


Seems like every time a Bush gets elected bad things happen to the average joe.
Turquoise
O Canada
+1,596|6831|North Carolina
I'm against it for the sake of American jobs.   I really don't give a damn how it helps or hurts Colombia.  What they do in their own country is their problem.
PureFodder
Member
+225|6711
Colombia has the highest rate of killing of trade unionists in the world.

HRW wrote:

Colombia has yet to show concrete results in breaking paramilitaries’ power and holding the killers of trade unionists accountable,” said José Miguel Vivanco, Americas director at Human Rights Watch. “If Congress ratifies the FTA now, it’s very unlikely the Uribe government will follow through on its promises to tackle these issues.

Paramilitary groups, which are on the US list of foreign terrorist organizations, have openly admitted to deliberately targeting unionists. Bush says the Colombian government has addressed the violence by demobilizing tens of thousands of paramilitary fighters. However, the Organization of American States (OAS) mission verifying the demobilizations has identified 22 illegal armed groups, in which paramilitaries are actively recruiting new troops and participating in drug trafficking, extortion, selective killings, and the forced displacement of thousands of civilians. Eight foreign embassies in Bogota, the OAS mission, and countless human rights defenders, trade unionists, and civilians have also reported receiving threats from these groups in recent months. 

Meanwhile, Colombian democracy is facing a serious threat in the form of paramilitaries exercising influence at some of the highest levels of government. More than 50 congressmen from Uribe’s governing coalition, his former intelligence chief, and other officials, have come under investigation for collaborating with paramilitaries. Rather than fully supporting investigations into these links, Uribe has repeatedly lashed out against the Colombian Supreme Court and journalists who are trying to uncover the extent of the paramilitaries’ influence.
Trade unionists aren't exactly in a society free from violence, murder and coercion.
FEOS
Bellicose Yankee Air Pirate
+1,182|6837|'Murka

Did you miss the part where over the past six years, deaths in the unions dropped 86%...due to reforms put in place by the Uribe administration?

Too bad HRW doesn't produce any statistics to show trends. Of course, that would probably work against their argument...
“Everybody is a genius. But if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing that it is stupid.”
― Albert Einstein

Doing the popular thing is not always right. Doing the right thing is not always popular

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard