Varegg wrote:
1. Larger gap between $0 and minimum wage = more people into work seeing as the gap is so small now it doesn't matter if you work or not.
2. More people into the work force = more tax dollars
3. Increased minimum wage does not increase illegal aliens, control your borders better.
4. With an increase in minimum wage of course the other rates should increase thus making the gap between unskilled and skilled labor the same.
5. A production cost increase ? ... you can't automatically state that for a fact, a better paid worker works harder and produces more so the increase in production cost does not equal the increased cost of labor.
6. The risk of inflation is not that big and can be countered easily with interest rates.
7. Tax return for businesses that doesn't downsize and moves their companies out of the country, again an increase in workers and more taxdollars that equals the corporate taxcuts.
8. Higher tax on corporate leader wages, what the bosses make should be taxed more so the money stays in the company, if a CO makes 19 or 20 million dollars after tax makes no biggy for him, but that million dollar can make a huge difference for his workers and in the end the company.
[/list]
Excellent. This is one of those pros & cons debates, a double edged sword really.
2. More people into the work force = more tax dollars. True. But how many new jobs were actually created? Increasing the wage rate increases the cost of doing business = either the company eats the difference or the price of goods is increased.
3. Control your borders better? Lets see. You're saying more people will be willing to work for minimum wage because they are being paid more, but an illegal aliens will not? Increasing the amount an illegal can get will increase the numbers coming over the border. So increasing the minimum wage makes it harder to control the border. And it's not like we can solve that without solving poverty in latin america anyway.
4 & 5. Your point 4 makes my point about increasing the cost to produce a product. A production cost increase - work harder? False. You've raised the minimum, which in turns raises the salaries of those working just above minimum wage, which increases the salaries of the managers, etc. Haven't you heard of "I'm not working for that...it's almost minimum wage"? So you've merely increased what people are paid...they don't get more motivated because of this. I do know there are studies that support that people are more motivated due to the gap...but what you've done is raised the minimum...the gap doesn't go away.
6. Interest rates? Like lowering them? Like reducing the value of the dollar aka inflation?
7. Assuming companies get a tax cut equal to the wage increase, then you won't have to raise the price of the product. However, if my factory has a large wage increase, aren't I going to eventually look at outsourcing? After all, I can shift everything to China & India and make more money because of lax labor laws. Then how many jobs have I created?
8. Raising the minimum wage rate will trickle all the way to the top. Albeit not as grand. A 10% increase in wages for the minimum wage worker might mean an 8% increase to the manager, a 6% for the regional manager, a 4% increase for the vice president, and a 1% increase for the CEO. Goes straight back to your #4 - there has to be a wage gap between the manager and the people he/she manages.
Increasing the minimum wage does not create jobs. It increases inflation.