nonsense. like saying all resistance to nazism was pointless and unworthy of comment because the final solution happened anyway.
No, your argument is that you can't lump in all nazis with the ones who ran the camps.
Sure there were some nazis who just joined up because their friends and family did and they thought they should go along, but as a group it is OK to say 'nazis bad'.
The fact is judaism has a tradition of genocide at its core and thats what they had planned for the Palestinians from day one of the zionist project.
Sure there were some nazis who just joined up because their friends and family did and they thought they should go along, but as a group it is OK to say 'nazis bad'.
The fact is judaism has a tradition of genocide at its core and thats what they had planned for the Palestinians from day one of the zionist project.
Fuck Israel
there is no "the fact is" about it. judaism pre-existed for millennia before the zionist project ever began. many jews never supported it whatsoever. now you're holding them as directly culpable and saying they've been genocidal from the start? no, that's not how it works. look at the plurality of christian denominations, sects, cults, whacko extremists, political nutjobs, etc. there's a very wide range of interpretation involved in these texts, and it's not at all the case that ALL jews GLOBALLY have always supported (a) the theology or (b) the political project of zionism. many jews have simply said No to that stuff all along, and have traditions/belief systems going back centuries before it ever existed. blaming ALL jews EVERYWHERE for that stuff is simply anti-semitic. this is your biggest blunder, because it blunts the very real criticisms to be made of israel when you start haranguing secular jews in the West for tihs stuff. they have as much in common with meshuggenah polacks like netanyahu as you or i do.
many jews have protested agaisnt the state of israel and its misdeeds/crimes from before day, arguing even against its conception. just like many people resisted nazism outright, not just went along with it as wehrmacht soldiers or whatever laughably thin reading list you continually draw upon for examples. i am not talking about compliant people who 'just followed orders': i'm talking about people who said No from the get go. there's a whole tradition of judaism that is explicitly anti-zionist ffs. those people are not negligible. you just ignore them because it doesn't suit your anti-semitic presentiments.
many jews have protested agaisnt the state of israel and its misdeeds/crimes from before day, arguing even against its conception. just like many people resisted nazism outright, not just went along with it as wehrmacht soldiers or whatever laughably thin reading list you continually draw upon for examples. i am not talking about compliant people who 'just followed orders': i'm talking about people who said No from the get go. there's a whole tradition of judaism that is explicitly anti-zionist ffs. those people are not negligible. you just ignore them because it doesn't suit your anti-semitic presentiments.
Last edited by uziq (2026-03-07 05:39:27)