BF2S Forums Saw III not as good

I thought the 3rd was the best of the bunch.

karks14 wrote:

its like they took out all the cool twists and replaced it with gore.

I haven't seen the third one yet but think about how lame it would be if at the end of the movie a twist happened like in the first too.  I'd prolly think to myself "wow a twist...didn't see that coming /sarcasm"

Would be pretty lame to do another end movie twist such as the first two, people would expect it.

stryyker wrote:

No story, horrible acting.

Even so, they were still great. imo

gburndred wrote:

I personally thought the movie was good, gory but still good. The twist at the end wasn't that good of one. I'd  expect more from it.

Saw is a movie based on this guy who would take people who did something wrong in their life and put them in terrible situations where the people would in a way kill themselves, rather than the guy killing them. One example was a guy wakes up in a basement and has 2 hours to get outside. The door will close and lock shut closing out his oxygen. The only problem is in between him and the door is hundreds and hundreds of yards of barbed wire. He ends up cutting himself so deeply stomach acid was found on the ground, but that's basically the idea to make them go crazy and technically kill themselves.

Anyways, I think the first was the best, followed by the second, and then followed by the third. I don't think the third was nearly as good as the first two but it's still a must see for the other Saw fans out there. SPOILERS They actually already announced Saw 4, but I don't see how they could possibly make that happen since Jigsaw is killed.

karks14 wrote:

its like they took out all the cool twists and replaced it with gore.

There were more twists than the last 2 combined.

The suckyness of Saw II should have been a pretty good indicator of how badly Saw III was going to suck.

I like the saw movies for the all out gore, but also for the surprise endings. III was better than I and II for gore, but the surprise ending, wasn't as sudden. A lot of people who go for the ending say they didn't like it because the ending was slightly more drawn out:

<spoilers>

The viewer knows JigSaw's apprentice (Amanda) is faltering when the female detective can't get out of her ribcage trap, and also when jig says that Amanda's life depends on the doctor, you can kinda tell that jigsaw is messing with Amanda too. The thing that I still enjoyed about the ending was how, by playing his last tape recording, jigsaw knew that the guy would lose his entire family (son, wife, and now his daughter is trapped). He says that there is one last game to play (when you see the girl through the keyhole). Another cool thing (for potential sequel / Saw IV) is how jigsaw says how the guy failed his test of forgiveness, and he can continue his wrath; jigsaw offers him all of his supplies and tools.

Anyway, the gore was spectacular, and the ending--for me--was still fulfilling. Nothing like the first one (OH SNAP THAT GUY ON THE FLOOR IS ALIVE!)

</spoilers>

The third Saw was actually my favorite installment in the series.

It's like all trilogys, First is the best, second is the worst  and the third is right in the middle, usualy pretty close to the best though.

third was the best. it was a smart one.