Your opinion on female sports commentators / experts?

2007-04-24 15:33:35

#1

CruZ4dR: Cereal Killer; +145|7106|The View From The Afternoon

In my opinion, female sports commentators are terrible. It seems wrong to me, no matter how fine the lady may be. I simply cannot concentrate to focus on what is being said.

I'm sure there are talented women out there who love sports just as much as me, but the thought of, for example, female soccer commentators is completely wrong to me. And here are probably some sports that would be more appropriate for women to commentate/debate. It's hard to explain why I feel like this but it just seems like women have a more "2D" view of what's going on out there, and when they "analyze" the gameplay it's like they read it out of a poorly written book.

I say let the women do the weather reports and sissy talkshows, but let those who know sports stick to commentating it.

-CruZ

2007-04-24 15:34:39

#2

GunSlinger OIF II: Banned.; +1,860|7094

sexist?

2007-04-24 15:35:04

#3

CruZ4dR: Cereal Killer; +145|7106|The View From The Afternoon

GunSlinger OIF II wrote:
sexist?

Not at all.

2007-04-24 15:35:17

#4

CameronPoe: Member; +2,925|7005

GunSlinger OIF II wrote:
sexist?

2007-04-24 15:35:33

#5

stryyker: bad touch; +1,682|7170|California

Anyone is better than Madden...

In the Madden games, you should be able to ask Madden and have him give you useful advice. Or say "Make me a Canoli, and then we will talk..."

Fat asshole Madden.

And yes, women can/should be doing it.

2007-04-24 15:37:33

#6

konfusion: mostly afk; +480|7000|CH/BR - in UK

I dunno. I can't stand hearing female women in Brazilian soccer - it just doesn't sound right. But that's how I've grown up with it. I'm not sexist in any way, but it just doesn't have the same feel to it.

-konfusion

2007-04-24 15:39:25

#7

CruZ4dR: Cereal Killer; +145|7106|The View From The Afternoon

stryyker wrote:
Anyone is better than Madden...

In the Madden games, you should be able to ask Madden and have him give you useful advice. Or say "Make me a Canoli, and then we will talk..."

Fat asshole Madden.

And yes, women can/should be doing it.

The way I feel, for men commentating sports it seems more like a hobby and you can tell when a person really likes what he/she is doing. I just don't feel that when watching female commentators/reportters live. Feels like they are reading off a piece of paper that's been written by a man.

lol.. no offense. Just my personal opinion.

Hope you don't get me wrong.

2007-04-24 15:45:32

#8

madmurre: I suspect something is amiss; +117|7160|Sweden

There are very few women commentating sports so when you encounter one who is really terrible at it it´s easy to generalise, Had one here in Sweden doing hockey.. Damn she´s terrible Sweden vs Russia, and only thing she keeps saying: the russian guy pass the puck to the other Russian guy who pass it on too another Russian. I almost instantly muted the TV and turn the radio on.

However there´s allot of competent women as well i´m happy as long a they put the best Man/Woman at the job.

2007-04-24 16:18:52

#9

Sanjaya: Banned; +40|6677

Who likes carpeting!?

2007-04-24 16:21:20

#10

m3thod: All kiiiiiiiiinds of gainz; +2,197|7121|UK

Sanjaya wrote:
Who likes carpeting!?

As in carpet munching?

Blackbelts are just whitebelts who have never quit.

2007-04-24 16:24:27

#11

Scorpion0x17: can detect anyone's visible post count...; +691|7216|Cambridge (UK)

madmurre wrote:
There´s a lot of competent women [commentators] as well. I´m happy as long as they put the best Man/Woman [in] the job.

2007-04-24 17:01:11

#12

l41e: Member; +677|7098

If a commentator (male or female) is so bad that if - with voice electronically scrambled - your ears bleed and the UN starts to investigate a possible violation of the Geneva Conventions, then they should be sacked. Not on the basis of gender.

2007-04-24 17:24:51

#13

Malfera: Member; +3|6971

I usually don't pay attention to what they're saying as I'm too busy checking out their tits and whether or not she's worthy of my schlong.

2007-04-24 17:25:54

#14

twiistaaa: Member; +87|7118|mexico

i heard somewhere that different parts of the brain are used to decipher men and womens speech. woman's uses the same parts as when your listening to music.

2007-04-24 17:27:25

#15

sergeriver: Cowboy from Hell; +1,928|7207|Argentina

They suck as sports commentators.

2007-04-24 17:29:34

#16

m3thod: All kiiiiiiiiinds of gainz; +2,197|7121|UK

i'd give sue barker one

Blackbelts are just whitebelts who have never quit.

2007-04-24 18:28:01

#17

Pug: UR father's brother's nephew's former roommate; +652|6992|Texas - Bigger than France

They're fine, as long as the reason they got the job is because they can do the job right, not because they got the stuff.

2007-04-24 19:04:36

#18

jonsimon: Member; +224|6945

I dont think there are many sports fanatic women out there who are really given the chance to do real analysis or comentating. All Ive ever seen are the lame reporters working the sidelines and feeding pre-written cues to athletes in interviews.

Edit: It also helps that male commentators are almost always former athletes/coaches.

Last edited by jonsimon (2007-04-24 19:05:58)

2007-04-24 19:08:03