TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica
Anyone hear about him being fired for giving "Kane and Lynch" a negative review?

WHAT THE HELL IS THAT!?

Discuss...
TimmmmaaaaH
Damn, I... had something for this
+725|6919|Brisbane, Australia

TrueMusou wrote:

WHAT THE HELL IS THAT!?
elite faggotry to the highest degree.
https://bf3s.com/sigs/5e6a35c97adb20771c7b713312c0307c23a7a36a.png
usmarine
Banned
+2,785|7242

I would bet there is more to it.  Two sides to every story.
TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica

usmarine2005 wrote:

I would bet there is more to it.  Two sides to every story.
Yea, I'd love to hear it.
nukchebi0
Пушкин, наше всё
+387|6804|New Haven, CT
Where can I read about this?
TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica

nukchebi0 wrote:

Where can I read about this?
google it.

Or go to Gamespot's forums.
OmniDeath
~
+726|7124

Look at some of the user reviews --> here
TimmmmaaaaH
Damn, I... had something for this
+725|6919|Brisbane, Australia

https://bf3s.com/sigs/5e6a35c97adb20771c7b713312c0307c23a7a36a.png
mtb0minime
minimember
+2,418|7134

Here's the video. I really want to hear the other side of the story to this. He did say "multiplayer is worth checking out if you don't have to pay full price", so maybe Gamespot thought he insinuated you should download it? Highly unlikely.

Last edited by mtb0minime (2007-12-03 01:57:01)

Uzique
dasein.
+2,865|6950

TimmmmaaaaH wrote:

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/aa240/cheet0bandit0/lolgamefaqs.jpg

LOL
That's kind of ridiculous. In the world of corporate-owned games review/entertainment, I'm pretty sure multi-billion dollar companies don't bow to 4chan-esque tactics. Works with 14 year olds, but I doubt fat-cats in suits are really bothered about a peasants revolt on their Forums.

It certainly sucks, if the reasons he was fired for are to be believed. I can only take my hat off to him for standing up against peer pressure from his superiors to accept an effective 'money-bribe' from a games company to peddle their products. Although, I'd also laugh and slap him, and tell him that smart people realize that working in a big company involves nothing more than sucking the cock of your superiors, dealing with your competitive subordinates, and trying to generally keep everyone happy so that you won't be fired on a whim.
libertarian benefit collector - anti-academic super-intellectual. http://mixlr.com/the-little-phrase/
Dragonclaw
Member
+186|6785|Florida

Uzique wrote:

TimmmmaaaaH wrote:

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/aa240/cheet0bandit0/lolgamefaqs.jpg

LOL
That's kind of ridiculous. In the world of corporate-owned games review/entertainment, I'm pretty sure multi-billion dollar companies don't bow to 4chan-esque tactics. Works with 14 year olds, but I doubt fat-cats in suits are really bothered about a peasants revolt on their Forums.

It certainly sucks, if the reasons he was fired for are to be believed. I can only take my hat off to him for standing up against peer pressure from his superiors to accept an effective 'money-bribe' from a games company to peddle their products. Although, I'd also laugh and slap him, and tell him that smart people realize that working in a big company involves nothing more than sucking the cock of your superiors, dealing with your competitive subordinates, and trying to generally keep everyone happy so that you won't be fired on a whim.
Most of those people were paying subscribers. They all canceled.
TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica

Uzique wrote:

TimmmmaaaaH wrote:

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/aa240/cheet0bandit0/lolgamefaqs.jpg

LOL
That's kind of ridiculous. In the world of corporate-owned games review/entertainment, I'm pretty sure multi-billion dollar companies don't bow to 4chan-esque tactics. Works with 14 year olds, but I doubt fat-cats in suits are really bothered about a peasants revolt on their Forums.

It certainly sucks, if the reasons he was fired for are to be believed. I can only take my hat off to him for standing up against peer pressure from his superiors to accept an effective 'money-bribe' from a games company to peddle their products. Although, I'd also laugh and slap him, and tell him that smart people realize that working in a big company involves nothing more than sucking the cock of your superiors, dealing with your competitive subordinates, and trying to generally keep everyone happy so that you won't be fired on a whim.
If smart means running against your ethics and values...I'd rather be a dumb-ass. Either way, I wanna see more of Gerstmann, just elsewhere besides GS.
Mekstizzle
WALKER
+3,611|7101|London, England
Is the game good or crap. I just want a normal review, what are balanced unbiased sites saying about the game?

It doesn't seem that bad.
killer21
Because f*ck you that's why.
+400|7071|Reisterstown, MD

GS bashes a lot of bad games..why is this one in particular getting so much attention?  That's lame if that is the reason why he got fired.
I'm Jamesey
Do a Research Noob
+506|6612|Scotland!

Mekstizzle wrote:

Is the game good or crap. I just want a normal review, what are balanced unbiased sites saying about the game?

It doesn't seem that bad.
I played it, it's not good. Uninstalled after about an hour.
TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica

killer21 wrote:

GS bashes a lot of bad games..why is this one in particular getting so much attention?  That's lame if that is the reason why he got fired.
I heard that Eidos or whoever produced the game had some sort of deal with GameSpot's parent company. They pressured Gamespot to get rid of Gerstmann because of the review.
nukchebi0
Пушкин, наше всё
+387|6804|New Haven, CT
Lawsuit.
Defiance
Member
+438|7151

TrueMusou wrote:

Anyone hear about him being fired for giving "Kane and Lynch" a negative review?

WHAT THE HELL IS THAT!?

Discuss...
It's a fucking rumor.

Yes it would suck if that was the case, though Gamespot doesn't strike me as a corporation above such things. Advertisement this, buy membership that yada yada.

Saying it like fact doesn't help the situation though. Reserve judgment until something official is released.

Last edited by Defiance (2007-12-03 19:11:02)

Darkhelmet
cereal killer
+233|7231|the middle of nowhere

mtb0minime wrote:

Here's the video. I really want to hear the other side of the story to this. He did say "multiplayer is worth checking out if you don't have to pay full price", so maybe Gamespot thought he insinuated you should download it? Highly unlikely.

He also said "FU** YOU!"
OmniDeath
~
+726|7124

Darkhelmet wrote:

mtb0minime wrote:

Here's the video. I really want to hear the other side of the story to this. He did say "multiplayer is worth checking out if you don't have to pay full price", so maybe Gamespot thought he insinuated you should download it? Highly unlikely.

He also said "FU** YOU!"
Oh noes!

Coming from a game where that's have the dialog... who cares?
Doctor Strangelove
Real Battlefield Veterinarian.
+1,758|6948

mtb0minime wrote:

Here's the video. I really want to hear the other side of the story to this. He did say "multiplayer is worth checking out if you don't have to pay full price", so maybe Gamespot thought he insinuated you should download it? Highly unlikely.

By "not pay full price" he undoubtedly means buy it used, I watched enough GS reviews to know that.
TrueMusou
Member
+36|6641|United States Of Hamerica
Oh yeah, they took that video review down from GameSpot's Video Review Archive. If that's saying anything...it's been said.

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard