Pages: 1

 

Poll

Which one?

Msi2%2% - 1
Asus61%61% - 22
Other36%36% - 13
Total: 36
2007-12-05 10:17:09
Lai
Member
+186|6629
A few minutes ago I got this offer from a store (I registered so it's not dodgy spam) for a videocard. Now I was planning on buying a new one anyway, but I'm not a proffesional gamer. E.g. I enjoy playing BF2 hotseat with my little brother (die and swap seats ) and it's just to increase performance (we currently play on an Ati x600 256mb passive cooling). In any case I'm not willing to spend more than a hundred euro's on upgrading a basic Dell PC. It's not about not having the money to pay, it's about just not being willing to pay (so please save me the; "save money for a Nvidia GTHZX 80K Quad-Sli" comments or something).



So this is the card I found, and I would like to know if it's any good, any significant improvement compared to what I got now.

http://www.informatique.nl/cgi-bin/iqsh … NB05122007

I also found this card. It has active cooling (me like fancy moving parts, but it may also mean an increase in power requirements and in the worst case having to upgrade my basic Dell PSU), dual DVI (I use VGA, but they can be plugged into DVI adapters and with a dual mode I can plug in two screens) and is faster (540Mhz instead of 460Mhz, does that matter much?). It does however cost 30 euros more (which is quite alot relatively in this price range) and is made by Asus instead of MSI (MSI is better right?). Evidently the Asus card may preform better, but which one is the best deal price/quality-wise?

http://www.informatique.nl/cgi-bin/iqsh … p;A=120007



Thanking you in advance,



* 1 pound sterling is worth 1.5 euros and I think 1 euro is worth about 1.5 dollars.
2007-12-05 10:21:59
Mekstizzle
WALKER
+3,611|7099|London, England
The 8600GT (Asus) is alot better. Out of those two, i'd go for that. You could easily play games like BF2 (BF2 quite well infact) and CoD4 with that card

an 8600GT for 98 Euro's is quite good actually

Although, try and get an 8600GT with 256MB and GDDR3 memory instead. Lemme see if I can find anything

Last edited by Mekstizzle (2007-12-05 10:22:58)

2007-12-05 11:06:35
aimless
Member
+166|6602|Texas
I would recommend this: http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics_2007.html but they dont have results for the x600 or the 8500. You can get an idea of how the 8600 performs compared to other cards though.
2007-12-05 11:09:53
max
Vela Incident
+1,652|7045|NYC / Hamburg

the 8600 is a lot more powerful than the 8500. The 8500 is more designed for HTPC use
once upon a midnight dreary, while i pron surfed, weak and weary, over many a strange and spurious site of ' hot  xxx galore'. While i clicked my fav'rite bookmark, suddenly there came a warning, and my heart was filled with mourning, mourning for my dear amour, " 'Tis not possible!", i muttered, " give me back my free hardcore!"..... quoth the server, 404.
2007-12-05 11:10:56
Dragonclaw
Member
+186|6783|Florida
If youre just going to be playing BF2 and not any DX10 games dont bother with an 8 series card, get a 7600, its cheaper and works just fine for DX9 games.

Last edited by Dragonclaw (2007-12-05 11:13:18)

2007-12-05 11:12:43
elite.mafia
Banned
+122|6931|USA
Neither of those are gaming cards. Get a 79xx series card.
2007-12-05 11:14:15
Dragonclaw
Member
+186|6783|Florida

elite.mafia wrote:

Neither of those are gaming cards. Get a 79xx series card.
I think the 7900 is way more expensive than the 8600. I could be wrong though but thats how the pricing is on newegg.
2007-12-05 11:18:01
Lai
Member
+186|6629

Mekstizzle wrote:

The 8600GT (Asus) is alot better. Out of those two, i'd go for that. You could easily play games like BF2 (BF2 quite well infact) and CoD4 with that card

an 8600GT for 98 Euro's is quite good actually

Although, try and get an 8600GT with 256MB and GDDR3 memory instead. Lemme see if I can find anything
What's the difference because I really don't know anything about GDDR3 memory .
2007-12-05 11:23:34
aimless
Member
+166|6602|Texas
GDDR3 memory is faster than GDDR2
2007-12-05 11:25:57
ELITE-UK
Scratching my back
+170|6952|SHEFFIELD, ENGLAND
*Waits for someone to say get a 8800GT* Looks in your direction Posideon
2007-12-05 11:27:48
elite.mafia
Banned
+122|6931|USA

Dragonclaw wrote:

elite.mafia wrote:

Neither of those are gaming cards. Get a 79xx series card.
I think the 7900 is way more expensive than the 8600. I could be wrong though but thats how the pricing is on newegg.
It doesn't matter. The 8600 is NOT a gaming card. Read up on it. It is meant for video editing / HD-dvd playback.
2007-12-05 11:31:55
Lai
Member
+186|6629

elite.mafia wrote:

Dragonclaw wrote:

elite.mafia wrote:

Neither of those are gaming cards. Get a 79xx series card.
I think the 7900 is way more expensive than the 8600. I could be wrong though but thats how the pricing is on newegg.
It doesn't matter. The 8600 is NOT a gaming card. Read up on it. It is meant for video editing / HD-dvd playback.
You know a card that is suitable for gaming, somewhere in the 50-100 euro pricerange?
2007-12-05 11:38:46
elite.mafia
Banned
+122|6931|USA
www.ebay.com
2007-12-05 11:40:30
Lai
Member
+186|6629

Dragonclaw wrote:

If youre just going to be playing BF2 and not any DX10 games dont bother with an 8 series card, get a 7600, its cheaper and works just fine for DX9 games.
Yep I'm playing on XP home, so that'll be DX9. But 7600 GS cards don't seem to be much cheaper, I might as well get an 8 series then right?



P.S. Other Specs: P4 630 (3.0Ghz 64-bit single-core) with BTX/CTX cooling (can't remember which one, but it is encased in a black box with a fan on the exterior) and 2Gb DC RAM.
2007-12-05 11:47:45
elite.mafia
Banned
+122|6931|USA
Take my advice.
Throw that computer in your garbage can and build your own.
2007-12-05 11:57:26
cian1500ww
Member
+8|6476|Ireland
Get an X1950PRO. Its a little dearer than 100 but well worth the money.
2007-12-05 12:07:52
Lai
Member
+186|6629

elite.mafia wrote:

Take my advice.
Throw that computer in your garbage can and build your own.
Like I said,.. I'm not a builder nor a gamer. I've got a PC on which I also game occasionally.
2007-12-05 14:41:35
elite.mafia
Banned
+122|6931|USA

Lai wrote:

elite.mafia wrote:

Take my advice.
Throw that computer in your garbage can and build your own.
Like I said,.. I'm not a builder nor a gamer. I've got a PC on which I also game occasionally.
... You can't upgrade BTX based dells. If you buy a 8600gt or w/e you won't be able to power the thing. It's going to be worthless, and a waste of your time. Just leave it be, or get a whole new system. Don't bother upgrading it.
2007-12-05 14:58:16
Lai
Member
+186|6629

elite.mafia wrote:

Lai wrote:

elite.mafia wrote:

Take my advice.
Throw that computer in your garbage can and build your own.
Like I said,.. I'm not a builder nor a gamer. I've got a PC on which I also game occasionally.
... You can't upgrade BTX based dells. If you buy a 8600gt or w/e you won't be able to power the thing. It's going to be worthless, and a waste of your time. Just leave it be, or get a whole new system. Don't bother upgrading it.
Why's that, because of the PSU? I can get a new PSU if it's absolutely necessary.
2007-12-08 07:20:56
Lai
Member
+186|6629

Mekstizzle wrote:

The 8600GT (Asus) is alot better. Out of those two, i'd go for that. You could easily play games like BF2 (BF2 quite well infact) and CoD4 with that card

an 8600GT for 98 Euro's is quite good actually

Although, try and get an 8600GT with 256MB and GDDR3 memory instead. Lemme see if I can find anything
Hey, you mean something like this? It costs the same and has passive cooling:

http://www.informatique.nl/cgi-bin/iqsh … p;A=120004
2007-12-08 07:50:09
Freezer7Pro
I don't come here a lot anymore.
+1,447|6675|Winland

Any graphics card will basically kill a BTX Dell. Sorry to say. Change to a real motherboard, chassis and PSU.
The idea of any hi-fi system is to reproduce the source material as faithfully as possible, and to deliberately add distortion to everything you hear (due to amplifier deficiencies) because it sounds 'nice' is simply not high fidelity. If that is what you want to hear then there is no problem with that, but by adding so much additional material (by way of harmonics and intermodulation) you have a tailored sound system, not a hi-fi. - Rod Elliot, ESP
2007-12-08 07:51:50
Mekstizzle
WALKER
+3,611|7099|London, England

Freezer7Pro wrote:

Any graphics card will basically kill a BTX Dell. Sorry to say. Change to a real motherboard, chassis and PSU.
No

Lai wrote:

Mekstizzle wrote:

The 8600GT (Asus) is alot better. Out of those two, i'd go for that. You could easily play games like BF2 (BF2 quite well infact) and CoD4 with that card

an 8600GT for 98 Euro's is quite good actually

Although, try and get an 8600GT with 256MB and GDDR3 memory instead. Lemme see if I can find anything
Hey, you mean something like this? It costs the same and has passive cooling:

http://www.informatique.nl/cgi-bin/iqsh … p;A=120004
Yes
2007-12-08 08:19:28
Lai
Member
+186|6629

elite.mafia wrote:

... You can't upgrade BTX based dells. If you buy a 8600gt or w/e you won't be able to power the thing. It's going to be worthless, and a waste of your time. Just leave it be, or get a whole new system. Don't bother upgrading it.

Freezer7Pro wrote:

Any graphics card will basically kill a BTX Dell. Sorry to say. Change to a real motherboard, chassis and PSU.
I don't mean to be rude, but such comments aren't really helpfull. If you make a comment like "your system sucks", I'm not unwilling to accept that it does; but I would appreciate if you could be a bit more specific. E.g. I have a PCI-E card in my Dell right now, so why would another card kill it; also please define "killing". Or why would one not be able to upgrade a BTX based Dell? It has different slots like any other PC with screws like any other PC and connected by cables like any other PC; what would deter me from say taking out my PSU and putting a new one in?
2007-12-08 09:10:42
Bertster7
Confused Pothead
+1,101|7059|SE London

Both make poor graphics cards. Of the 2 Asus are certainly the better choice.
2007-12-08 09:19:58
Freezer7Pro
I don't come here a lot anymore.
+1,447|6675|Winland

Lai wrote:

elite.mafia wrote:

... You can't upgrade BTX based dells. If you buy a 8600gt or w/e you won't be able to power the thing. It's going to be worthless, and a waste of your time. Just leave it be, or get a whole new system. Don't bother upgrading it.

Freezer7Pro wrote:

Any graphics card will basically kill a BTX Dell. Sorry to say. Change to a real motherboard, chassis and PSU.
I don't mean to be rude, but such comments aren't really helpfull. If you make a comment like "your system sucks", I'm not unwilling to accept that it does; but I would appreciate if you could be a bit more specific. E.g. I have a PCI-E card in my Dell right now, so why would another card kill it; also please define "killing". Or why would one not be able to upgrade a BTX based Dell? It has different slots like any other PC with screws like any other PC and connected by cables like any other PC; what would deter me from say taking out my PSU and putting a new one in?
I'm not saying your PC sucks; I have a P4 630 as my primary gaming computer's CPU myself. What I'm saying is, that the power supplies Dell gives away with their BTX computers are shit, and it seems like the motherboards aren't very compatible with anything. I have first-hand experience from that. The one I had had a retarded PSU in all ways. Could only find new ones from the Dell site, and they went for 100+€ for 400w...
The idea of any hi-fi system is to reproduce the source material as faithfully as possible, and to deliberately add distortion to everything you hear (due to amplifier deficiencies) because it sounds 'nice' is simply not high fidelity. If that is what you want to hear then there is no problem with that, but by adding so much additional material (by way of harmonics and intermodulation) you have a tailored sound system, not a hi-fi. - Rod Elliot, ESP

 

Pages: 1

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard