Poll

I agree with the following statement...

Israel deserves to keep WB, Gaza and East Jerusalem16%16% - 13
WB, Gaza and East Jerusalem Belong to Palestine25%25% - 20
Palestine keeps WB, and Israel Gaza and E. Jerusalem10%10% - 8
Gtfo47%47% - 37
Total: 78
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

CameronPoe wrote:

M.O.A.B wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:


Spearhead I do preach non-interventionism and isolationism, which is made difficult by those who can't abide by their own borders.
But what I don't understand is they're not your borders, so why leave your isolationist ideas to worry about the borders of another coutnry?
It's the principle of the thing. It stems from what happened to my own country at the hands of the Brits.
Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?


I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

M.O.A.B wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

usmarine2005 wrote:


unless he changed his mind, he has said he is an isolationist.
Spearhead I do preach non-interventionism and isolationism, which is made difficult by those who can't abide by their own borders.
But what I don't understand is they're not your borders, so why leave your isolationist ideas to worry about the borders of another coutnry?
You can still be an isolationist and protest for the crimes commited in other country.  He's not asking to invade Israel.  Maybe some UN sanctions would be fine.  Oh, wait that isn't possible coz of the veto.  Damnit.
CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|6992

Cougar wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

M.O.A.B wrote:


But what I don't understand is they're not your borders, so why leave your isolationist ideas to worry about the borders of another coutnry?
It's the principle of the thing. It stems from what happened to my own country at the hands of the Brits.
Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?

I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
Your point is perfectly valid but this is a discussion forum where a great many things over which we can have no control gets discussed. It's just conversation at the end of the day Cougar.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

Cougar wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

M.O.A.B wrote:


But what I don't understand is they're not your borders, so why leave your isolationist ideas to worry about the borders of another coutnry?
It's the principle of the thing. It stems from what happened to my own country at the hands of the Brits.
Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?


I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
With your line of thinking nobody would 'waste' his time to support oppressed people.  If everyone cares, someone should listen, some day.
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

CameronPoe wrote:

Cougar wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:


It's the principle of the thing. It stems from what happened to my own country at the hands of the Brits.
Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?

I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
Your point is perfectly valid but this is a discussion forum where a great many things over which we can have no control gets discussed. It's just conversation at the end of the day Cougar.
When it gets discussed everyday for 2 years, I think the topic evolves into something more than that.  I think this topic has been beaten to death, buried, drug up and beaten again even harder.

I really don't see the point of even discussing it any longer.
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

sergeriver wrote:

Cougar wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:


It's the principle of the thing. It stems from what happened to my own country at the hands of the Brits.
Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?


I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
With your line of thinking nobody would 'waste' his time to support oppressed people.  If everyone cares, someone should listen, some day.
No.  Actually they won't.


I would love to see you prove your point against.....lets say, STALIN.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

Cougar wrote:

sergeriver wrote:

Cougar wrote:


Well I don't think Britain fucked Ireland anywhere near as hard as Israel fucks Palestine. 

But honestly, I do wonder why you care so much.  No matter how many people you talk to about it, how many forums you post on about it, or how far and wide you can spread your message, it is never going to change anything.  Israel will do what Israel wants to do and no one can change that.  They do not care about sanctions, resolutions or any wrist slaps the U.N. hands out, why would they care about what any of you people think?


I think the best we can do is shut up, tune in, watch, listen and hope for the best.
With your line of thinking nobody would 'waste' his time to support oppressed people.  If everyone cares, someone should listen, some day.
No.  Actually they won't.


I would love to see you prove your point against.....lets say, STALIN.
There was no internet back then.
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

sergeriver wrote:

Cougar wrote:

sergeriver wrote:


With your line of thinking nobody would 'waste' his time to support oppressed people.  If everyone cares, someone should listen, some day.
No.  Actually they won't.


I would love to see you prove your point against.....lets say, STALIN.
There was no internet back then.
Yes because the internet can and will topple governments.

No.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

Cougar wrote:

sergeriver wrote:

Cougar wrote:


No.  Actually they won't.


I would love to see you prove your point against.....lets say, STALIN.
There was no internet back then.
Yes because the internet can and will topple governments.

No.
No, people can.
rawls2
Mr. Bigglesworth
+89|6997
My solution: "The Great Build"-A contribution of $$ from all the big countries to an Israeli/Palestinian fund set up to build settlements for Palestinians built by Palestinians. Get them working, put them in a home, put up Palestinian flags and hope the violence ends long enought to see this happen. Then it wont be so hard for Israel to recognize a Pal state.
CameronPoe
Member
+2,925|6992

Cougar wrote:

When it gets discussed everyday for 2 years, I think the topic evolves into something more than that.  I think this topic has been beaten to death, buried, drug up and beaten again even harder.

I really don't see the point of even discussing it any longer.
I don't enjoy the same old tired arguments either Cougar but I do bring up discussion when a development may have occurred, such as Mike Huckabee's stated stance on the matter and the implications of it or a step forward in the peace process. Seriously, I do not enjoy having to repeat the details of the Balfour Declaration or the sequence of events in 1967 to every newbie on the forum but it's hard to get people not to digress to such matters.

PS I think you're overstating the frequency with which the topic is discussed. It just so happens it's in the news right now.

Last edited by CameronPoe (2007-12-17 13:49:52)

Kmar
Truth is my Bitch
+5,695|7038|132 and Bush

CameronPoe wrote:

Seriously, I do not enjoy having to repeat the details of the Balfour Declaration or the sequence of events in 1967 to every newbie on the forum but it's hard to get people not to digress to such matters.
You should try and squeeze the breakdown in your signature.
Xbone Stormsurgezz
M.O.A.B
'Light 'em up!'
+1,220|6660|Escea

Kmarion wrote:

CameronPoe wrote:

Seriously, I do not enjoy having to repeat the details of the Balfour Declaration or the sequence of events in 1967 to every newbie on the forum but it's hard to get people not to digress to such matters.
You should try and squeeze the breakdown in your signature.
lol on size 2 font
Dilbert_X
The X stands for
+1,822|6543|eXtreme to the maX
My solution: "The Great Build"-A contribution of $$ from all the big countries to an Israeli/Palestinian fund set up to build settlements for Palestinians built by Palestinians. Get them working, put them in a home, put up Palestinian flags and hope the violence ends long enought to see this happen. Then it wont be so hard for Israel to recognize a Pal state.
How about we build these Palestinian settlements in Israel? Bulldoze a few jewish homes, shoot a few kids in the head etc to make some space.
Seems fair...
Fuck Israel
M.O.A.B
'Light 'em up!'
+1,220|6660|Escea

Dilbert_X wrote:

My solution: "The Great Build"-A contribution of $$ from all the big countries to an Israeli/Palestinian fund set up to build settlements for Palestinians built by Palestinians. Get them working, put them in a home, put up Palestinian flags and hope the violence ends long enought to see this happen. Then it wont be so hard for Israel to recognize a Pal state.
How about we build these Palestinian settlements in Israel? Bulldoze a few jewish homes, shoot a few kids in the head etc to make some space.
Seems fair...
O--K
rawls2
Mr. Bigglesworth
+89|6997

Dilbert_X wrote:

My solution: "The Great Build"-A contribution of $$ from all the big countries to an Israeli/Palestinian fund set up to build settlements for Palestinians built by Palestinians. Get them working, put them in a home, put up Palestinian flags and hope the violence ends long enought to see this happen. Then it wont be so hard for Israel to recognize a Pal state.
How about we build these Palestinian settlements in Israel? Bulldoze a few jewish homes, shoot a few kids in the head etc to make some space.
Seems fair...
Great, meet an honest possible sulution with a response like that....drop dead.

And for the record...the plan is to build, not destroy.

Last edited by rawls2 (2007-12-17 15:05:42)

chuyskywalker
Admin
+2,439|7285|"Frisco"

Cougar & sergeriver: I don't really care who started it -- either you discuss things civilly or you can both take a vacation from posting.
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas
Works for me.
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

chuyskywalker wrote:

Cougar & sergeriver: I don't really care who started it -- either you discuss things civilly or you can both take a vacation from posting.
You are the boss.
DesertFox-
The very model of a modern major general
+796|7122|United States of America
Within the title question, what are the OT's?
sergeriver
Cowboy from Hell
+1,928|7194|Argentina

DesertFox- wrote:

Within the title question, what are the OT's?
Occupied Territories, sorry, lol.  I was at work.
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

sergeriver wrote:

chuyskywalker wrote:

Cougar & sergeriver: I don't really care who started it -- either you discuss things civilly or you can both take a vacation from posting.
You are the boss.
So......


Anyways, what I meant by the first statement before you flew off on me was that in powerful countries such as the U.S., Britain, China, Russia, etc etc, people will not and do not topple the governments in this day and age. 

1. Because the majority are complacent and would rather endure the problems than to put forth an effort to change it.

2. Because in China and Russia they would shoot anyone at the first sign of rebellion. (China doesn't even let people Google FFS and Russia kills journalists)

3. Because the populations are so widely polarized any sign of rebellion could be passed off as the "non-patriotic other guys" starting trouble and the other half would fight them, thus starting a civil war instead of a revolution.


However, in third world or under-developed countries like your own (you told me yourself that it sucked), the people CAN because:

1. The majority of people are not complacent because of poor living conditions, poverty, hunger, etc and WOULD put forth the effort to change it because they have nothing to lose.

2. Because the governments are not large or indoctrinated enough to find any rebellion and quell it from the start as a larger much older country can.

3. Because the populations are either a) not polarized to the degree that the major western countries are, b) because the governments are not sophisticated enough to play their own people against each other or c) not well rooted enough to garner any major support in the event of an uprising.



So therefore, people really can't change a whole lot in developed countries such as mine but are much more likely to in countries such as yours.  Israel would fall under the "not able to be changed by peoples wants' category.


Respeck.
IG-Calibre
comhalta
+226|7179|Tír Eoghan, Tuaisceart Éireann
So who do you think hounded Tony Blair out of office this year in Britain?
Cougar
Banned
+1,962|7202|Dallas

IG-Calibre wrote:

So who do you think hounded Tony Blair out of office this year in Britain?
Tony Blair is not the British Government.  Tony Blair was the PM.
Kmar
Truth is my Bitch
+5,695|7038|132 and Bush

Consider what peace with Israel - real peace - would mean in the West Bank and Gaza, in southern Lebanon and the Bekaa Valley: Tens of thousands of gunmen (and terrorists) out of work, with no marketable skills - and radicalized by decades of fanatic rhetoric.
This would be funny if it wasn't sad and disappointing.
Xbone Stormsurgezz

Board footer

Privacy Policy - © 2025 Jeff Minard